OCHA
by arianto

Comment:
Sorry, I don't see this frame as meeting the challenge, which says to use a foreground element as the frame, not to construct one in Photoshop.

Between the Branches
by ChikaZAWa

Comment:
You'd have a much stronger sense of framing if you had cropped out the top two flowers. One of them is seriously out of focus; you could cut the other just below the green center.

My Garden
by lukyn

Comment:
I don't really see a frame here. I like the picture, but not for this challenge.

Moonlight Snack
by Tygerr

Comment:
Beautiful!
This is one shot that loses a lot by having to scroll through it, rather than seeing it as a whole (I don't take off points for that - it's just frustrating). That's always a tradeoff in vertical shots - a good size versus the inability of many monitors to take in the whole shot at once.

Jonathan Livingston Seagull
by Rando D300

Comment:
Nice frame - the framing adds a lot here - the gull would be lost without it.

vanessa
by kiwinick

Comment:
Nice shot, nice model. Unfortunately, I have to guess what the picture looks like as a whole, since it won't all fit on my monitor. This doesn't lower the score, but it is irritating.
I know the maximum size is 640 pixels, but in a vertical shot that means it is too big for many monitors. That's always a tradeoff in vertical shots - a good size versus the inability to take in the whole shot at once.

Pike's window
by spartacus9

Comment:
Great texture in the "frame," and a nice view inside.

A Wire!
by errasmus

Comment:
Sorry, but I don't see the wire as a frame, more as a line across the out of focus background. This might work better in the current challenge, which emphasizes an out of focus background to bring out the subject.

Little girl in the big city
by Elvis_L

Comment:
She's cute, but too dark and small relative to the rest of the picture. Cropping at the top of the inner (lower) curve of the arch would help. That's how I see the picture on my monitor, since it's too deep to fit in one go.
That's always a tradeoff in vertical shots - a good size versus the inability of many monitors to take in the whole shot at once, but in this case a tighter crop at the top would solve that problem and make for a better picture.

Triplets
by sunrise

Comment:
Beautiful, the way the flowers partially escape from the frame.