Totally Chill
by dwyllie

Comment:
Greetings from the DPC Critique Club:

I realize that this is late in coming, but Critique Club members have been backlogged with current challenges and recently got caught up enough to go back a bit in the request queue. I voted in this challenge and gave you a 9. Absolutely loved this shot. It's at an unusual angle and didn't immediately give itself up as a bottle and cap. Once that became clear the technical excellence became even more apparent. Amazing sharpness and detail, perfect strobe technique and spot on exposure. I don't think I can tell you a thing that would make it better, or would explain your lower end votes. Maybe chalk it up to a commonplace subject that was easily identified, and therefore not abstract enough. Who knows. It's a great photo. I'd be proud as heck if I was behind the lens. Kudos.

The Blob
by OK-Photography

Comment:
OK,

From the DPL Critique Club: This is a strong entry for the Abstract in Green challenge. I had no idea you could get this type of effect with just water and cream. Very nice. What I like is the randomness of the submerged form. It tells an interesting story about the fluid dynamics. While the background yellow blends well with the green, I wonder what a more contrasting color might have done here. Finally, the shapes in the background are effective, but they appear to not be symmetrical from left to right. This may be a result of the mass of cream being larger on the right and obscuring the background. I do like the color gradient change in the background, your gel use was effective in creating this lighting pattern.

Domino Theory
by Barroness

Comment:
Slinky?

pool party
by 2mccs

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #1o in my random voting thread: Hmmm... it does look a trio of legs and feet underwater at first glance. I still imagine what ever it is, is submerged in clear liquid, but that may be just the power of suggestion from the first impression and the title. Curious.

Prepare for Reentry Mr. Spock!
by wdamman

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #9 in my random voting thread: A gas burner of some type - bunson? torch?

Red and Gold
by jnenvir

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #8 in my random voting thread: Some kind of decorative metal work. Nice composition.

Puzzle Macro
by SEG

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #7 in my random voting thread: Some kind of thorny plant, but I can't seem to place it in full context.

Mineral
by SaraR

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #5 in my random voting thread: I don't have a clue what this is. Some kind of tool or piece of a larger machine. Nicely converted.

Vanishing Point
by grahamgator

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #4 in my random voting thread: This is really well done. The composition and DOF creating an interesting bokeh pattern in the background are great and the silver/green color palette is a good choice. I the main subject is hammered metallic - some kind of container with dark liquid? Really.. I have no idea.

symbiosis
by mefnj

Comment:
For the First Ten! side challenge - This is image #3 in my random voting thread: I don't have a clue what this is. The primary subject seems like it might be an LED.