Dunce
by banmorn

Comment:
It's a funny take. It gives off that modern message on manhood... Women rule, men drool. I think it needs a more centered composition and the rotation looks off a hair, but it could be an illusion.

Dance of the Dragons
by BrianR

Comment:
It's rather a flat image due to the lack of range in tones. Also I think a hand holding the fan would have added a lot to the image!

#600519
by rooum

Comment:
High key and Sepia too! I thought you may be referring to an older image by your title, but apparently not...

Garlic
by IreneM

Comment:
Great lighting and wonderful use of form and shape to create something visually "appealing" if I can use a pun. The smaller garlic looks like a snail! Great sepia tones too. Lovely browns!

O-R-E-O again
by jbirkman

Comment:
Well I looked and saw a few oreo shots similar to this one so I don't know what the original was therefore I can't really comment on your improvement like I would like to for this challenge. However I can comment on this image. I am no lighting expert but the first thing that sticks out to me is the background highlighted area. I think it should be bigger. Also the choice of color lighting and the dark shade of it makes the picture look a little murky. I am kind of seeing some orange glow on the edges of the glass where the should be highlights from backlighting or side lighting. Other than those lighting issues, which I could not even come close to replicating, you have a clean, crisp image that makes me want to eat an oreo!

Summers Work
by BaldurT

Comment:
I think you really lost the whites in the toning process which makes the image look flat. There is less depth.

A Day's Work
by mariuca

Comment:
A good re-shoot of your work and an improvement at that. I like the angle better and the light is softer which looks good. The artwork looks like it is steaming!!

Nailed
by hernan43

Comment:
There's nothing really wrong with the picture's technicals... good light, good focus, nice range of tones. I think the subject matter is kind of bringing it down for me

Vendor water break...!
by lobrin

Comment:
Sharp and crisp! That eye is a little creepy!

Falls with heron
by rhoadesurf

Comment:
Good capture of the Heron in a somewhat hostile environment sitting there peacefully. I think the reds are a bit too red in your tones. It has bled into the water.