(Rescuing over and underexposed images)
by njsabs

Comment:
I'll assume you nailed the tutorial.

Selective Desaturation
by Bear_Music

Comment:
This is good and the tutorial worked well for you. THe only problem I see is the use of selective desaturation is in my opinion supposed to provide a pop of color to act as the focal point, Here, the focal point is caused more by the compositional technique of filling the frame and the selective desat acts as secondary. At any rate it's a good photo with lots of detail in the tomato.

Blue reflections
by jimsapp

Comment:
You did good with the horizon line being on the third and capturing the reflections. Unfortunately there was nothing of real interest captured in the landscape.

The Thin Blue Line
by Leo

Comment:
Such a good concept. The fact that the reflection of the blue background is all over the metal really kills this. That metal shield and the cap badge need to be crisp and silver and shiny. I am not sure if you are using a blue light or not but I think this could have been done on white and it would have really gotten the point across.

Wildlife Photography Tips: Take Better Wildlife Photos
by mbrutus2009

Comment:
Very awesome shot. I like the pose captured and the glare looking right out to the viewer puts the viewer in the scene. I think this is a bit underexposed unless you were going for a low key effect. Other than that, the only thing I could think of changing would be the use of rule of thirds. But that has no affect on the vote.

Bokeh
by posthumous

Comment:
This looks pretty over exposed which far outweighs the small bokeh shown.

Glass and crystal photography
by rhoadesurf

Comment:
I think this is super sharp and crisp. The lighting is great!! No reflections to notice and no real hot spots. I think the only nit pick would be the color choice for the BG. Green on blue... I would like to see white, black or a complimentary color for the green.

A LONG EXPOSURE of a stare
by Gengi

Comment:
I like the sky and the reflections. I think the photo overall lacks sharpness and detail and it has a funky red cast throughout. Possibly needs some color correction. Good concept and for improvement I would say to get closer to the subject.

Lone majesty
by abspro

Comment:
I love tree shots and I think you did good here. You got the right angle and perspective on the tree. It is a hair off of rule of thirds for composition which detracts. You are also running into the same problem I have around here... lone trees in the field with a tree line in the background. The best solitary tree shots are shot with a very bare background and great sky!

Cosmic Neighbour
by jimness

Comment:
This is definitely a distant object. I think the concept of the challenge was a little lost due to the fact you brought the distant image close to the viewer with a telephoto lens. But certainly it is not DNMC. A great moon!