Dark Princess Clarinet
by Deen

Comment:
I'm not sure that cutting off the top was a good choice. It almost looks like an accident instead of a conscious choice...

Into the black...
by Vidomatic

Comment:
Strangely enough, I would have liked this better centered (and I'm usually a big fan of negative space. Perhaps because it's such an interesting face and it has intensity; it feels like the intensity is lost over on the side.

Minimalism in Black
by Judi4Me

Comment:
I do like this one. I'm wondering if you're getting hit by people saying that the background is grey, not black.

Grandpa's Tractor
by Lydia

Comment:
I love the top part of the photo, and I don't usually mind things disappearing, but I really think that on this shot, it would have been better to see the whole tractor. 6 for that lighting on the top, probably would have been an 8 if you had the whole tractor.

Only the lonely
by quiet_observation

Comment:
I'm wondering if you've done something like this before... It looks very familiar. Anyway, I think it's spectacular! 10

Equal spaces between
by hojop25

Comment:
sorry -- that's really pushing it, imo. I think you should be able to look a a picture and have a vague idea of what the challenge is about. I had no idea what your three was until I looked at the title. Imo, DNMC.

However, that being said, I think it's a very interesting, very intriguing photo. I wish it was in free study, or someplace that it fit a little more. So sorry!

Cycle-Shoe-Rescue
by drydoc

Comment:
I'm so sorry, but there's just too many subjects. I looked at the picture before I read the title, and I would have thought your subjects were the shoe, helmet and cycle, or perhaps shoe, cycle and truck. It really was more of an all things being equal: five.

Sorry, DNMC, imo.

2 ducks for 1 fish
by redpanda

Comment:
Couple of things:

nit pick -- the fish isn't really equivalent, he blends in, and I didn't particularly notice him until I read the title. It doesn't really affect my vote, however.

It seems very oversaturated on my monitor. And I wish the angle was a little more from the right so that you could see more than just the back of the female's head.

untitled
by eyeduphotos

Comment:
Great shot!! But then again, I'm partial to gulls... :)

Identical Flashlets
by daevans

Comment:
Would have liked this better without the reflections. They're so pale, it doesn't really add much interest, imo. Sorry!