Serenita al Crepuscolo
by FourPointX

Comment:
I like the shot, but I'm not sure that the fence adds that much to it (and I love fences!) The sunset and the palm trees and reflection are so wonderful, I would have liked it zoomed it quite a bit more. (not voting yet)

On the Seawall
by crik

Comment:
I adore pelicans, and it's a wonderful shot as well!

An American Cocker Spaniel
by Alain

Comment:
Sweet photo. Great intensity. Very small thing -- I would have liked it shifted over to the right just a tad. The back isn't as interesting, it would have given the dog more space to look out. It's not quite centered, it's not rule of thirds, at it doesn't have to be, but it feels just a little lopsided. (I hope that makes sense. It doesn't make any difference in my vote -- it was a small thing that would make the composition feel a little better, imho...) -7-

The South Korean Wicker People
by cowboy221977

Comment:
Wow! Really cool photo! Clever idea. I do think that the white line going across is quite distracting, though. It would have been much stronger if you could have cloned it out or darkened it somehow so that it wasn't so obvious. -7- (8 or possibly 9 without the line)

The Bridge of Sighs
by kaiser_chief

Comment:
Lovely shot and nicely done. I'm curious what it would have looked like if you cropped out the left side. The boat on the right is so superior to the boat on the left, and the bridge and the building are so much more interesting than the tree, that I wonder if cropped out the left, leaving the right boat at the left 1/3 line might strength it even more. -7-

Sasaki III
by zeuszen

Comment:
I wasn't sure when this first came up. I think maybe it seemed a tad washed out. Yet the more I look at it, more contrast would be the wrong thing. However, I really like the grain in this shot -- it adds quite a bit to the photo. It was a 6 in initial reaction and quickly grew to an 8 as I continued to ponder it. Here's to hoping that everyone takes the time to ponder it!

Frozen Powder
by tehben

Comment:
Congrats on your new PB and a top 10! I thought this was a truly awesome shot -- my only 10 given in the challenge.

Inferno
by PhotoDave

Comment:
Definitely the right choice of photographs -- though the out takes are wonderful! This one is truly spectacular.

Instinct
by Lutchenko

Comment:
Congrats on the top 10!! whoot!

Shirt-Pocket Tripod
by GeneralE

Comment:
I'm very surprised at the placement of this one. I thought it was an excellent product shot -- and I like the contrast! Very nicely done!