Alone
by gyaban

Comment:
I love reading your comments after the challenge!

What a great image! What an awesome score! What a beautiful piece of work! Massive congrats on the PB and well over 8+! :)

Dreamland - Edgar Allan Poe
by Judi

Comment:
Oh my!!! I'm so glad you put up the contact sheet of the photos -- truly impressive!!

Huge, huge congrats on the 8, the PB, and the awesome image! JulietNN is right -- there are not enough words!!

Autumn's Natural Ribbon
by Lydia

Comment:
hehe!! I love it! Very nice job for a first pumpkin carving. :)

You never carved pumpkins as a kid??

Pumkin
by kvair1

Comment:
I really wish this was in color. I love the idea and the angle, but it loses something in b&w translation. :)

Alone
by gyaban

Comment:
Absolutely adore the bend in the trees. What a great look and spectacular idea! The grave stones amongst the trees were a great touch!

The Mind Macabre
by mefnj

Comment:
Wasn't sure I liked the editing on the person. The forehead seems to take over the shot. And the sharpness of the mind vs the soft grittiness of the face seems to interrupt the flow and bring the focus more to the face than the mind. (also, the hands in the background are really dark. I've looked through this challenge about 5 times before voting and never noticed the hands.) I wish the darks either weren't as dark, or the hightlights were taken down a bit so that it flowed together a little more.

However, that all being said, I like the idea, I like the crop on the face with just the eyes at the bottom, and I like that there's a lot to explore. :) -7-

Eleonora
by neenee1999

Comment:
Incredibly beautiful!

The Tell-Tale Heart
by Tommy_Mac

Comment:
Awesome!! -8-

"The City in the Sea" Published 1831
by Dennisheckman

Comment:
Very fun idea -- nice on to explore. You don't see death right away, which is great, because you feel like you've found a treasure when you see him. But if he's reflected so well in the water, wouldn't the railings be reflected as well? Still, very nice. -8-

The Beating of the Tell-Tale Heart
by markwiley

Comment:
Extremely well done, imo. In a challenge with some truly spectacular expert editing, this one holds its own. -8-