Window Dressing
by GeneralE

Comment:
Ummm... So you're trying to draw our eye to whats on the thirds?! :P

Survival in a Harsh Environment
by hahn23

Comment:
Nice. Small thing -- I wish there were more contrast, especially with your title. It's really quite peaceful as it is now, and doesn't speak harsh at all to me.

Three on a Third
by Lydia

Comment:
Quite cool -- but the sky is just too overdone, IMO, plus it really brings out the sensor dust. Taking it down quite a bit would have given it even a greater sense of depth and emptiness. It hurts the photo, imo. Sorry

Stairs
by mitalapo

Comment:
Don't know on this one. Technically, does it meet rule of thirds? Yes and no. But close enough. The idea is really intriguing. I guess I wish that the hand was a little more blurred or sharper. It's uncomfortably blurry, which makes me just want to rub my eyes. So while I really really want to like it, because it's quite cool, it doesn't quite work.

end of season
by tvsometime

Comment:
I like it quite a bit, but I wish it wasn't cropped so high -- that there was a little more head space for our person. It feels a little claustrophobic. Other than that, nicely seen and captured.

Painting the sunrise
by P-A-U-L

Comment:
Intriguing. I wish there wasn't so much dark space at the bottom, or that perhaps there was a little bit of detail in it. But the rest is really nice.

trek
by HUETH

Comment:
Haha!

It looks like you forced the 1/3, but I actually like the negative space in this.

The eagle has not yet landed
by skewsme

Comment:
That's not an eagle. I'm studying to be a master naturalist and I know my birds. It looks like either a pterodactyl or a pteranodon. :) Fun catch.

Getting There
by posthumous

Comment:
Again -- another where I would actually like the subject to be on the 1/3 both vertically and horizontally. Too much foreground which isn't as interesting as the background. I think moving the biker down would be more interesting.

A Quick Rest
by grahamgator

Comment:
Very nicely done, but I think the crop is actually a bit uncomfortable. This is one of the few times where I really would have liked to have the butterfly on the true 1/3 (vertically and horizontally), not just vertically. Otherwise nicely done. Looks like an American Lady?