THE WALL
by Antithesis

Comment:
Good perspective shot, but maybe just a little tight on the angle. Colr seems very good. Focus is good. Framing - seems O.K. to me. 8 Swash

Abandoned Silo
by LindaLee

Comment:
Good perspective shot. Strong focus and very good color. Challenge - well met. Interest - mederate. Detail - good. Framing - O.K. 8 Swash

Regret
by arnit

Comment:
Very sharp, well contrasted shot. Pretty model! Nice framing. Challenge aspect - I'm not certain I get it....viewing up at her?? (let's just not push this too much, I'll give you back the point I took away for my not understanding!) 8 Swash

Shipmates of Bontekoe
by Azrifel

Comment:
Very clear shot, but a little dark. Challenge - I'll buy it. Interest level - moderate. My eyes keep being drawn to the light at the top of the wall (Not certain if this is a good thing or not, but I don't think so.....On the other hand, it is kinda out of your control...got a sling shot? 7 Swash

Heat
by Alecia

Comment:
Comment didn't stick - Good photo! Nice color, good focus, framing - well, I'll go personal taste there. Lighting - while it seems bright would be needed to light the degree tags, the glare is a bit harsh. The curvature of the glass distorts the image, but I'm not certain if that's a good thing or a bad thing (no score affect).
7 Swash

It's Just A Game
by Shiiizzzam

Comment:
Very good photo. Extremely clear, even though white on white, well done! Challenge aspect - I'm just not certain how this fits, but I'm not wholly cruel, so I won't nail you HARD for that (and my ignorance of the subject). Very detailed!
7 Swash

vood's hairy back
by johnny_justjohnny

Comment:
Well done "tatoo". Color seems pretty good. Framing works well enough, lighting too. Challenge aspect - well, cute/funny, but IMHO not really as requested by the challenge. Background - busy and not additive to subject. Effort - relatively high.
7 Swash

WinterTrees
by Remie

Comment:
Neat row of trees. Contrasts are pretty good, but the tangle of branches takes away some of the clarity that strong contrast usually offers. 7 Swash

Coming out to get ya!
by Yomi

Comment:
Very scary! Good shot! Color seems very good. Focus is a narrow DOF, which works, but I would have preferred from the tip of his nose to eyes, rather than from the eyes back. In focus parts are very detailed. I really like the reflections in it's eye. Challenge met. 7 Swash

Incarceration
by dimitrii

Comment:
Are these handcuffs? (maybe an older design?) Interesting how you focused on the far "cuff" and not on the nearer one (that's kinda nice/different). Framing - works well enough, lined up basically on the 1/3 line. Color - well, there's not alot to work with there (no score affect). Interest moderate to good. Score upgrade from 7 to 8. Swash