Cardigan
by stephan

Comment:
The sweater creates an interesting pattern, but I still think this is "side stepping" the challenge. Technically speaking, you are shooting the air holes between the materiel of the sweater. Now, I think about it, I scored the chiffon shots well, O.K. I am going to change my mind and go with this, but it's pushing it.
photo 6 Transparency 6 total 6 swash

Happy Hour
by Diamondgirl

Comment:
Reflection and transparency both, interesting. two things - the double glass fuzzes the reflection a bit too much and i see vertical rainbow lines that I can't explain, but mess with the shot, could be grain. Photo 5 Transparency 6 total 6 swash

Cupid's Smile
by arnit

Comment:
Did you write on a window or is this a transparency page? Very artistically done. Could have been a Valentine's Day card. Suggestion: Use a piece of wide lined paper taped to the window, write your text, then remove the paper, if transparency paper, it's even easier. I don't like the lines. Photo 9 Transparency 8 total 9 swash

Mint Tint
by urbrider

Comment:
Interesting shot, but the sun's glare really hurt the overal presentation. Photo 7 Transparency 7 total 7 swash

Trasparent Focus
by B3D

Comment:
Interesting, but difficult to see what this is/what is going on. I like the colors and lighting, but don't "get" the subject. Photo 6 Transparency 7 total 7 Swash

Squint!
by Gordon

Comment:
You're right, but squint HARD. No fair. Seriously, Very nicely done, its suggestive/provocative without offending, very nice. Photo 8 Transparency 8 Total 8 swash

Blue Morning
by lmhr

Comment:
Feels like home. I like the rain rivulet going down the center. Nice touch. You're gonna hate this, but it's a bit dark, duh. (I should have backspaced that).
Photo 9 Transparency 8 total 8 swash

Stained Glass Perspective
by shortredneck

Comment:
Nicely done. Well executed, very minor, but I might have liked the rose more in the green area. Very clear stained glass. Photo 8 Transparency 8 total 8 swash

Gerbera jamesonii
by superdne

Comment:
Interesting effect to use the distortion of the glass to distort the flower. Nice job. (Did my monitor go dim, everything seems dark.....) Photo 7 Transparency 7 total 7 swash

Why the Long Face?
by Gotcha

Comment:
Great effect, but seems more like a mirror. Others in this challenge have found good glass that distorts somewhat like this, so I will give you the benefit of the doubt. (if mirror, please deduct 5 points) Photo 8 transparency 7 total 7 swash