Leaded Glass
by DigiPique

Comment:
The hand set glass in the lead frames offers a jigsaw effect that is bizarre and wonderful! Good eye! I just don't see anything to NOT like about this photo. It doesn't quite have 10 punch, but it's soooo close. High 9, Swash

Tranquility
by kathleenm

Comment:
Really pretty photo. Interest level in my view is modest. Still great shot. 9 Swash

Spoon Light
by jpoole

Comment:
Not a lot of detail to look at, other than the mat. Nicely spaced lights reflecting back. Well photographed, but a little low on interest. 7 Swash

Entrance to mirrorland through a looking lens
by johnmk

Comment:
Alice, me thinks you're mixing your metaphores again, lay off the 'scrooms! (Title Joke)
The number of panes of glass in the photo adds extra reflection lines, I am assuming you were aware of this. Picture raises more questions than it answers (i.e. what's that object or light, etc.) 7 Swash

The Past
by daysez

Comment:
An alternative definition of reflection, very creative, but risky for "popular" review. Good foto. 8 Swash

Bee-ond the glass
by guybrowme

Comment:
I can't imagine how you did this, but it looks really cool. Is this a double exposure? If it is, I don't really think that was the intent of the challenge and I will ask you to mentally lower the score I give to you by 2 points. 8 Swash

Reflection without mirror.
by RobCoe

Comment:
Cool balls, but the hand isn't enough to fully "hide" your camera. Shots works well in B&W, but the glare of the sun is pretty potent. Very good focus, nice framing. Challenge aspects, close, but not quite the cigar! 6 Swash

Reflections of a Star
by ABatsEyeView

Comment:
Let's start with, I know it's hard to get a good shot of the moon, but the crispness isn't very strong. Next, tell me there's a visual reflection here and I will up your score. While using alternate definitions of reflection IS creative, it is my belief this skirts the INTENT of the challenge, so scoring you highly would be an afront to those that worked to have a visual reflection. (Fair?) 5 Swash

First Submission
by jlr

Comment:
Title - going for voter sympathy? Interesting, but low on reflection. 7 Swash

Head & Shoulders
by Damitriel

Comment:
Nice macro! Yes, it reflects, but the reflections are very clear (I know the surfaces are big enough...) How about 7? Swash