Photoworld Magazine: Is digital taking over?
by aui

Comment:
Great concept, but to work as a magazine cover, you might have to rethink your placement of the rolls of film in proximity to the disk. I know it may seem like I'm being too picky, but when I look at the shot, the first thing I'm thinking of is "would this work as a magazine cover?" Once you add the words that appear on any magazine cover, it might not work as it is. However, I do like the shot a lot, especially since you created something that fits neatly into your article title.

The Kitchen Garden
by Lizz

Comment:
This is one of my favorites. It would look great as a magazine cover because of the placement on the page, but also because the colors and textures are so vivid. It would have been nice had a little bug not gotten to the leaves since I would think a gardening magazine of any kind would try to feature a near-perfect plant on their cover...unless of course the cover article is about how to deal with plant-eating bugs. LOL Anyway, I think you fit the criteria of the challenge very nicely with this shot.

Soccer Monthly - we let the cat out of the bag on goal scoring secrets
by wahoo

Comment:
Because of the cropping, this feels more like an accompanying article photo than the magazine cover shot. I like the sub-heading though. Cute.

Outside
by bosniak

Comment:
I can definitely see this as a magazine cover. You have allowed room for the wording that would appear on the front and your shot certainly pertains to the content of the magazine. The amber behind the silhouette of the grass is very beautiful.

Nature
by shadow

Comment:
Different cropping might have allowed me to see it differently, but it just doesn't look like a magazine cover to me.

Wildlife Conservation....http://wcs.org/
by Gracious

Comment:
This is a nice photo and very appropriate for your magazine cover. The placement of the subject allows for the magazine title and article blurbs. As far as the photo itself is concerned, I particularly like the ripples of the water toward the top of the page.

Retired Living
by jdw91479

Comment:
Nice concept but the photo doesn't seem cropped for a magazine cover so it doesn't quite fit the challenge for me. I also think it would have been more effective on a bright, sunny day rather than the overcast.

National Geographic
by InnaN

Comment:
Looks like the real deal!

Corn Syrup, Freshly Squeezed
by ScottK

Comment:
I love this!

Liquid Tomato...aka..Tomato Soup
by Girl from OZ

Comment:
This is a great photo. It looks like an ad in a magazine. The colors and lighting are wonderful and I love the cropping. Very nice.