On the Crossroads to ...
by Moose101

Comment:
I like this. However, wish the car was more to the right to be on the right third instead of dead center. 5

Strange Orbit of a Strange Planet
by sfalice

Comment:
This is a photo I really wanted to like a lot. The composition, and subjects look fascinating. However the depth of field/focus just makes me not want to look at it. I think a larger DOF would help it tremendously. Also, be careful with the unsharp mask as it is causing a little haloing on your photo. If it happens, you can always smudge it back carefully.

Enter the 36 Chambers
by justinbrook

Comment:
Has a 'Prince of Persia' look to it more than a ShaoLin Monk look, but that's ok, I still like the photo. Possible a tighter crop on the bottom and right would give it more appeal. 6

Subspace Entrance
by Dax-

Comment:
Bumping this one up, colors and lighting are very good. 8

Bot
by caba

Comment:
The lighting on this toy? gives it the air of realism. Do wish the left hand edge would be included in the photo and the light? in front of the right hand wing would be removed/cloned out. 6

Vistage of Atlantis
by whatdewuc

Comment:
Beautiful gradiant in the sunset. I just wish that it tied more closely to the theme. If I go with your title of Atlantis, to make it fit in, I can't imagine there being a shore with trees that close to the remnants of a destroyed civilization. But I'll give the benefit of the doubt. 6

The Ruthless General Cabot Ldl Kelp of Centurion 5
by Tallbloke

Comment:
Definitely think this is the best of the 'character' shots in the challenge. I do like the look of it. I would clone out what look to be the 2 fingers, as they do not appear to be attached to the body, and add nothing to the photo.

Free world
by heida

Comment:
Seems like we've seen this beach before... What are the circles to the bottom left of her foot in the clouds? Wait, I'm now guessing that they are supposed to be bubbles. I see them on her dress. It may be the limitation in the picture size, but at this size they look like imperfections (either bad clones or water spots).

Escape
by nico_blue

Comment:
Good ghostly image here. I wish that the ghosty image had the same 'ghostiness' from the head to the arm. On second contemplation, maybe you were trying to show the light causing the true ethereal nature of the ghost to be revealed while the arm in darkness continues the 'reality' of the dream.

Monsters!
by Matthew

Comment:
Definitely otherworldly. Lighting works very well on this. Seems like the face is a tad soft, but I do like the photo. 7