Tomato Guts
by Lorelei916

Comment:
EXTREME CLOSEUP! (This Wayne's World moment brought to you by...)

Sorta liquidy, yeah, very moist at least. I think the extreme closeup is, well, a bit extreme; more attractive to me would have been tomato slices that were 'bleeding', so to speak.

Technicolor Martini
by scab-lab

Comment:
Interesting angle, use of colour. Ultimately too much blue on blue for me but a nice idea anyhow.

Liquid Gold
by orussell

Comment:
So little of the shot is on the liquid here... it's too bad you couldn't get a larger stream.

Who's been drinking my juice?
by lordrich

Comment:
I would have rathered NOT grayscale to make it more obvious it's juice.

Also, I'd rather it through the juice; at this the eyes are drawn away from the liquid by the keys -- oh, hey, a Russian keyboard... er, anyhow, see?

It's kind of an interesting idea but the execution didn't grab me -- izvinitye!

Anticipation
by adine

Comment:
Look, I'm producing some liquid of my own! *wipes drool away*

Wow. That's, um, EXTREMELY appetizing-looking. Well-framed, good close-up shot, nice that the chocolate is dripping from the bottom to help emphasize it's in liquid form. The fork is nicely non-intrusive. My only complaint here is I don't get any. Oh, and the border's a touch distracting.

Bubbles
by BobsterLobster

Comment:
Ironically, I just saw a another bubble photo. Darn randomizer.

Again, I concede it's technically on topic, and in fact as you caught the motion of the bubble being blown, possibly a bit more so than the prior example. I like that there's multiple bubbles about; it makes it more interesting. It also works for me in B&W, which is not always the case with B&W photos. Overall I like it.

Bubble Liquid
by Lizz

Comment:
...okay. The exterior IS liquid on a bubble like this, I suppose, looked at a certain way. I'll call it 'on topic, for the most part', even though it's probably a better example of a gaseous subject. Or the principles of physics and surface tension. Or something. Anyhow.

It's a neat idea, and the bubblemass itself is very cool looking with the iridescence, but it's a pity you couldn't do the shot so the bubble was against the sky -- or did it stand out better against the cloud? Something about the clouds and sky look off... a bit of grain is visible, and maybe the light level seems wrong for the angle of the light and the glare. Not sure.

Tears
by sagestudio

Comment:
sigh.

Second tear picture I've seen, and second time I've had to decide if I think 'tears' are 'water'. Still debating.

The setup is fairly good, but the corner with the nostril is a little unattractive and also eye-pulling. It's somewhat on the bright side, and with the iris/pupil the only thing really dark that tends to pull the eye as well although that's not as bad as you can see the start of a tear there, though I'd rather something pulled the eye towards the falling one.

Glass of Milk
by Sappy

Comment:
On topic, along with an unfortunate number of others. I'm losing my enthusiasm on commenting on this type of shot, but let's see... the splashes on the side of the glass help with the topical connection... the background works better than I'd think for light-on-light until the bottom where it's overly bright... it looks strangely yellow at pour point; is it cream or buttermilk, or is that just the lighting?

GOOD MORNING !
by Bitz

Comment:
What surprises me less than all the syrup shots in the challenge is that I never once thought of it.

It's fairly appetizing-looking, which is a plus. The pitcher-pour looks natural. With as much plate surrounding the pancakes as you have I think I might have liked to see patterned dishware instead. Maybe a bit on the bright side.