Borderline
by nickyb

Comment:
I'm really trying to feel this - I get that you are shouting something out loud. Not sure what though.

light in the darkness
by posthumous

Comment:
(Critique Club!)

Posthumous, I've been away for over a year and you haven't changed - still knocking out images which are visually striking and yet don't seem to attract the scores. I guess the voters haven't changed either...

All my usual comments on technical stuff are irrelevant - I think I can see where you wanted to go with this and you have nailed it. Artistically? The contrast, the balance of light and dark in the composition, the positioning of the 'eye' area is all spot on. Criticism? "I got nuthin'" - sorry. Love it.

I'd print this A1 sized and hang it on my wall.

Cheers,

Frank.

OOOH! Colors!
by RileyBear

Comment:
Hi Tonya,

Welcome to the Critique Zone! Health warning: everything I have to say is completely subjective...

Fireworks shots are really hard to take - I know, I've tried and I'm no expert, so congratulations on getting this one nailed. Getting the firework shot while still making everything else look good is even harder.

Technically

This is slightly soft - hard to fix in camera so perhaps some PP sharpening to make it pop more? It may also be worth trying to see what happens if you use a tripod and longer exposure (and lower ISO to compensate)

Artistically

There is a lot going on in this shot - between the trees, the second firework and the cable bottom right, the eye is drawn all over the place which does detract from the focus. Difficult to know where the firework is going to off, so one way around this is to take a reasonably wide area and then crop down tight on the bit you want to focus on later - totally possible with the number of Mega Px in a 60D!

This shot looks like a great learning experience - I hope you enjoyed taking it. If you get good at firework shots, let me know and I'll come pestering you for 'how to' advice!

Cheers,

Frank.

Simplicity
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
HI Doc, welcome to the Critique Zone (disclaimer: everything below is completely subjective!)

For me, this is so nearly a killer shot. The shape, the pattern and the lighting are really 'zen' and actually change the way I am breathing. Your control of DOF is excellent but I agree with the commenter that I would have preferred to have the rim and pattern really sharp to contrast with the gentle blur elsewhere. For me, the dark pattern provides an ideal focal point, curling perpendicular to the light shape - if you really did not set this up, it is quite some serendipity!

Artistically, I find the yellow book distracting - actually all of them. without then, this becomes minimalist and very beautiful.

All I can say is that your absence has not cost your skill or your 'eye', welcome back!

Cheers,

Frank

Fantastical life
by snaffles

Comment:
Hi Susan - I hope that you went and bought this anyway!

What can I say? I like it, but I love shiny things so that was a given. What else can I say?

Technicals

I think that this shot concept really demands razor sharpness and good long DOF and you have delivered both here. The lighting is great with plenty of sparkle.

Artistically

I'm asking myself why this didn't break 6 at least. Hmmm. My best guess is that there is not enough contrast between the T-bar shape at the front and the background glass - more light in one or dark in the other might have helped (in PP I guess?) If I stare long enough, the brown 'lozenge' on the lower right also doesn't seem to quite fit?

Overall, I like it, you like it. Mainly I think that it might be a bit too 'busy' for the voters (checking out the very simplistic concepts in the top ten) but that is their choice and their loss.

Cheers,

Frank

A Kiss
by rooum

Comment:
Hi Clive - surprised to see you looking for a critique?! This is going to be tricky! I'm going to have to nitpick...

Technicals

I'm not sure I have anything to add. Could it be sharper? Probably - but I don't think it would be appropriate.

Artistically

I really like the concept and I'm 99% sold on the result. With the benefit of not being the guy standing on the hill taking the shot and capturing the moment, I would have placed the couple a tiny titchy bit further right and up in the composition. At the moment, my instinct keeps screaming that her foot has been cut off - I know it hasn't but that is the visual effect.

Overall, nice work - I'm sure that the lucky couple were thrilled!

Cheers,

Frank

Cousins Catchin' Crickets
by photokop

Comment:
Hi Mike,

Welcome to the Critique Zone! Please remember that this is all entirely subjective...

Technicals

It's a nice, sharp photo and fairly clear. You have all the key points in focus etc. However, given your proven skill in managing the DOF I am surprised that you did not go for a shallower DOF to bring my eye onto the kids and blur out the background which is not that interesting. While there is generally plenty of light, I also would (20/20 hindsight!) have used a little fill flash to light up your grand-daughter's face a little and kill off that unfortunate shadow.

Artistic

I would guess that this is a candid snapshot from the look of it, which is fine as far as it goes but for me the composition doesn't quite work - I find that cutting off the edges of the bodies is a little visually uncomfortable. I would suggest either capturing the entire body or focusing in more tightly and really making me focus on their faces and the great expressions of interest and playing. Perhaps moving away and using your 70-210 racked out to blur out the background and tighten in the field of view?

Overall, it definitely fits the challenge and, as a candid, works quite well but I think that driving the viewers focus more specifically could have resulted in a truly great shot here.

Cheers,

Frank.

Absolut: So Good 2 out 5 Can't Resist Drinking Irresponsibly
by aprudhomme

Comment:
Hi Alex, welcome to the Critique Zone!

I think that you are beating yourself up unnecessarily in the photographers comments. This is a really nice shot. Clinical, to be sure, but that's also the nature of Vodka so why not? You seem to be developing a somewhat minimalist, clean style and I, for one, quite like it.

There's really not a lot to critique - you have nailed the technicals from where I'm sitting. The lighting and 'tone' is spot on and whatever PP you have done works well. If I was being picky, the limitations are in the reflections in the bottle (a doorframe on the left and something dark on the right), and in being able to see the edge of the table - but that is really nitpicking - I'm not sure if the rules would allow you to make the table edge shadow disappear but it would be risky.

Overall, a really nice take on the challenge.

Happy hunting,

Frank.

Absolut Before: The Root of It All
by adigitalromance

Comment:
Hi T.Aaron, welcome to the Critique Zone!

What a great idea - kudos to you on both the concept and execution. I think that you pretty much nailed what you were trying to do here so this will be a really short critique!

This needs to be sharp, and it is - a classic example of how the kit lens is so much more capable than it is often credited with. The lighting is spot on, the perspective works etc etc.

You have produced a great illusion - I want to see the bottle even though my brain tells me it isn't there. The only way that this could be better (I don't feel the need for the top right of the bottle to be perfect!) would be if you could arrange an absolut label in the middle - but it would have to be perfect in order to not hurt the rest of the image.

Great job, hopefully a sign of more genius to come!

Happy hunting,

Frank.

ON THE ROCKS
by dreambigxoxo

Comment:
Hi Michelle, welcome to the Critique Zone!

First off, this is a great idea and I am very impressed by the dedication you put into realising your vision. Hopefully you still have the bottle because I think you could re-shoot this (if only for your own pleasure).

Technical: Your aperture is pretty wide for a shot of this nature, and the edges of the bottle are consequently a little fuzzy. I'd have used your 18-55 kit lens instead, set to about f7.1 and done it all with a tripod and delay / remote - that way you get a really sharp image, which this concept demands. The kit lens can be very good, so don't listen to all of the naysayers and stories. With a tripod, you can drop the ISO and use whatever shutter you need - it's still life, it's not going anywhere!

PP: You noted that you desaturated and used brightness / contrast - these are pretty blunt instruments. Have a look at the curves and b/w conversion tools in the lessons on DPC for some ideas on how to retain more control - there is some great knowledge in there. Also worth knowing that re-sizing can destroy sharpness, I always re-sharpen after re-sizing, just a little bot less so it doesn't look crazy.

Artistic: This shot starts from a great point: the glitter and glow, the contrast and lighting are really smart. I think that the perspective could be more interesting though - maybe offset, maybe looking up at the bottle? Something a little more unusual than the every day perspective we might see from our own eyes. Also, on DPC people are really picky and the dented cap is an issue for an 'ad' challenge where the bottle should be new.

I think that with a slight re-framing, this shot could be a killer, although the beads don't look like ice so I would have gone with 'abolut gem' or some such. You clearly have a great eye for the unusual, and I look forward to seeing more of your work.

Happy hunting,

Frank.