dinner money
by agwright

Comment:
Interesting idea, but a little bland on the presentation.

Pylon
by gerard

Comment:
Hello from the critique club :)

I like the symmetry of the shapes in this shot. The only problem with the shapes is that it pulls my eyes from one place to another. There seems to be no firm focal point.

The photo itself is a bit on the dark side as well.

Overall, however, I believe this was one of the better shots of the symmetry challenge. It met the challenge and did so with obvious talent.

Just a dumbell
by kiwiness

Comment:
Hello from the Critique Club!

This, as you already know from its finish in the challenge, is a wonderful shot! I liked this one when I saw it in the voting.

The focus is crisp and clear, the DOF is interesting and easily directs the eye to a focal point.

I love the silky texture of the metal. Texture is often so difficult to capture, but you've done it here.

I think it's harder to critique the good shots :). This one is wonderful and the ribbon well-deserved.

Shari

Urban Rainbow
by jgal76

Comment:
Good idea, but the cropping detracts from the image.

Northumberland
by howza

Comment:
Too much foreground detracts from the visual impact of the colors.

Tactile Calculations of Pi
by dsidwell

Comment:
Good DOF and nice sharp focus bring out some wonderful details.

Banana Pi
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Cute but overly bright...maybe less of the white background?

Aurora
by mcmurma

Comment:
Wonderful colors and great shot!

Grocery Store
by pitsaman

Comment:
I like the neon sign portion, but the red in the windows is distracting.

3 Signs of Pi
by dg02

Comment:
Nice shot. Interesting interpretive approach too.