My son Leifur
by tyrkinn

Comment:
Bad Points: way too much neatimage or whatever has given the smooth effect
Good Points: skint tones are well done
Overall Score: 2

Our Troops
by BigMo

Comment:
Bad Points: bad exposure, the dog tags are over exped, clumsy composition
Good Points: a nice idea, and full marks for trying something different.
Overall Score: 4

"I'm thankful for my new home"
by ladpupmoe

Comment:
Bad Points: bad composition, a crop on the dogs head would be better.
Good Points: lighting and exposure superb.
Overall Score: 4

Flipin' My Family "the bird"
by joannadiva

Comment:
Bad Points: Your thankful for Turkey? ;) Composition a touch off. Missing part of the bird on the right.
Good Points: great color and technicaly very good.
Overall Score: 4

Life on Tap
by Imagineer

Comment:
Bad Points: Fuzzing and banding on the left - the purple line. Overall looks blandish
Good Points: nice capture of water - different.
Overall Score: 4

My Pride and My Joy
by TooCool

Comment:
Bad Points: Grain, not enough to be arty, too much to be nice. The womans head looks strained.
Good Points: Nice composition idea, only let down by the womans pose
Overall Score: 5

Little boy and his monkeys in the streets of New Delhi
by Hardfire

Comment:
Bad Points: image format is too long for my taste -not sure about the suprise - he doesn't look suprised
Good Points: as a reportage shot, this is tops. A great effort. But for the suprise...mm?
Overall Score: 4

Daaaad!!
by cbeller

Comment:
Bad Points: Skin is too soft and makes it look OOF, being near a toilet doesn't make for a pretty picture ;) Also no eye contact!
Good Points: nice candid capture. Looks old.
Overall Score: 4

You drive me nuts
by darix

Comment:
super idea and great composition. I think the added motion blur is very nice and well done. But overall it seems a touch over exposed. Looking at the edge of the driver and the top of the nut. Which is a real shame as it degrades the image a little.

also is that a TaylorMade Bubble burner? Used to have one myself, great little club.

8! may come back and up it to 9 later.

Can of worms
by kiwiness

Comment:
super idea and super shot, not a bad thing to say about it. by far the best in this challenge and will be a worthy winner if I may say so myself.