Winter sea
by Rino63

Comment:
Good seascape, but don't seem to me to be on target for the challenge. I like seeing the weather, but would not want to be there.

earthy
by ordinaryangel

Comment:
Good idea to shoot in the dark. It makes the bottom of the water have detail. Fish eye look sucks you into this one too. It's a mucky looking place.

OINK
by whiteroom

Comment:
A classic dirt shot. Nobody knows dirt better than Mr Oink!

Wet Forest Floor
by Omni

Comment:
I wonder what that is at the top. This image seems to be busy, with no simple way to look from one side to the other without getting tangled up in the middle. I just drift around without finding a strong visual hook. I'm not trying to be mean, just honest about my personal response. I appreciate it when others are with me, as it helps me to set higher expectations for my work.

Pretty In Pink
by Judi

Comment:
Looks a bit hard lighted for me. I feel like she's mad about having to be this dirty for some reason. I think that it's because there's no dirt on the pink, and that makes it look just not quite "candid".

Make Mine, Dirt A Touch of Fertilizer & Water……Please
by BrianR

Comment:
Colorful props for the dark background. Smiley face for a happy picture.

One Load at a Time...
by JEFFJSB

Comment:
I feel it would be better with some action. I see that there's no operator in the cab. I understand that it isn't always easy to get this kind of shot on construction or mining places due to insurance regs ect. I miss the smoke, dust, and noise part of this one.

Life Lines
by Giorgio

Comment:
This looks honest. Good title, and the subject stands out over the background as it should.

Dirty Business
by EssAreDubya

Comment:
Fits the theme, just don't seem to have the "punch" that it needs to stand out. Tech is good.

Down the Road
by Jutilda

Comment:
What a pleasing photo! I enjoy shooting scenes like this too, but don't have the software to do the magic after the capture. Thanks for posting it.