Pie Are Squared (πr²)
by ClubJuggle

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Met the challenge, but the play on words may have turned some people off.

Composition: As clever and creative as this shot it, it does come off a bit flat. Did you use an on-camera flash for lighting? The blue plate adds some nice contrast.

Overall: Very cute idea and a very refreshing change to the pi (pie) competition!

Pretty in Green
by Sonifo

Comment:
CONGRATS TO YOU!!!!! You really have the knack! Great job!

#1 Key
by WILDBLUE

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Although this is a great photo, I think your only downfall is that it does not meet the challenge which called for a natural occuring number.

Technical: Your camera settings appear correct because of the clarity of the keys. Your lighting is great, and the composition looks good too. You may have wanted to spotlight the center key a bit more, as the focus seems to be on all of the keys, even though they are all pointing to the center.

Style: Very creative and fun to look at.

Overall: A great photo that only scored low because it did not meet the challenge criteria.

Alien
by Geocide

Comment:
One of my top picks for the week - I'm sure you'll be in the top 5!

Kitchen Artistry
by DougPaz

Comment:
WOW!!!! VERY CLEVER!!!! Do I dare ask how long it took you to make this??? This is really fabulous - you could start a wedding business - catering/photography all in one! GREAT CREATIVE SHOT!

A glass of bubbly
by Geocide

Comment:
LOL - great title and a great shot, although it does seel like your DOF is too shallow - the base of the glass is a little too blurry IMO, but this is still a fun shot.

Carbs...Just look! Don't touch!
by Patzt

Comment:
Hilarious title! I am trying to cut back on carbs, and talk about hard! You're just making it harder - yum!! Great shot, but looks like you might have used the flash???

Dusty old soup tureen
by Gotchya

Comment:
LOVE your lighting, and I love old weathered feel to this. Fabulous work!

Liquid Life
by Tarbini

Comment:
I think this is the winner - I keep coming back to it over and over. I love the angle of this, particularly because I don't know how you accomplished it - self timer? Someone kneeling at chest level?? The fact that I have to keep guessing even improves the image. I've been giving out plenty of 7s and 8s this week, but you are my first 10. I'll be VERY surprised if you don't finish in the top 3.

Sugar & Spice
by ChrisW123

Comment:
I love your style. This has an older, fun feel to it. The focus is really off - I think you may have oversharpened it, but I'm sure the original is phenomenal.