Seven (Calla Lily Stems)
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Beautiful - I absolutely LOVE the lighting and the color. Very pretty.

Two Still Standing
by Gallatin

Comment:
Nice shot! I think it would have looked better in color, but your cropping is very nice!

Curved like the number.....
by clues56

Comment:
I think the sidewalk is manmade, still a great shot.

Sixty Three
by Gotcha

Comment:
Great eye, and a very clever way to meet the challenge! Seems a bit busy, but I still like it and the quality is fantastic.

Sandstone Zero
by mcmurma

Comment:
Neat - I love the colors.

- 9 -
by Gotchya

Comment:
Very cool - I think it would have been better in color though (just an opinion)

Eleven
by Gracious

Comment:
Beautiful! I really love this!

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Met the challenge perfectly, but a little too much focus is on the flower.

Technique: Your lighting is awesome! The colors are very warm and inviting, and the "off centered" approach makes it interesting to look at. The reflection is great and very "clean"

Overall: A GREAT shot! I scored this one a 7 in the competition, and it is very well done. Very original and fun to look at.

Silo
by BAMartin

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Meets the challenge, but the line is a little detracting, like it ends before it reaches the barn. It's a great landscape picture!

Technique: I can see you went to the end of the line which was good, but I think if you would have crouched down and focused on the line instead of the barn, it would have been more impactful, while giving more attention to the line. I would be curious how this picture looks in a sepia tone. I think the colors, etc would make some great sepia hues.

Overall: A great job, and you followed the challenge rules well. There is a little noise to clear up, but that's easy to do "post-challenge". I would be curious how this would look at a lower angle.
'

Luminous
by greenem2

Comment:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Met the challenge perfectly, while still maintaining originality and creativity.

Technique: Clever! This is really a gorgeous shot that should have scored a bit higher in my opinion. It has a very "high-tech" look and feel to it. I am curious how you got it to stand up on it's own.

Overall: I really don't see anything I would change here. Your lighting and cropping are awesome, and nothing detracts from the image. I apologize for the short critique, but this really is WELL DONE!