Canada Lynx on Alert
by scalvert

Comment:
I am not sure how to judge this one because the square catch lights in the eyes makes it look like it may be captive animal which would make it questionable as far as the challenge so I am not going to judge it in case I am wrong. Pretty cool cat though, kind of wish the top of the ears were not cut off but still a nice shot. Good luck in the challenge.

Colour Inside the Lines
by hotpasta

Comment:
Very nice image, I think the desat was a perfect choice and very well done. As for the DQ, not as big fan of the rule or how it has been applied past or present. Congrats on a top image!

Bottle, rain and tree
by hajeka

Comment:
Pretty cool scene, If I could make a suggestion, I would crop in a little tighter to get rid of the legs of the table and the black edges and the items sticking into the frame. Those items just distract from the bottle and the rainy fall scene which to me are the focal points of the shot. Items that do not add to a photo tend to distract and get peoples attention away from the focal point of the photo. If I were to crop this shot I would crop the bottom up until the openings between the legs disappear, crop the right to where the gap between the table disappears and crop the left side and top to where the protrusions disappear. Good luck in the challenge.

They came at night
by bobcc

Comment:
Interesting choice to use B&W for a balloon burn shot. I am used to seeing the glowing colors in these type shots but I find the B&W strangely compelling and interesting. I love how the B&W accentuates the texture of the balloon and how the light from the burner is lighting the crowd up. Well captured and framed, good luck in the challenge!

Rusty Shack
by orvaratli

Comment:
I am always so jealous of Northern Light photos, it is a sight I want to see some day. I love the processing on this shot, the tones of the building work beautifully with the lights. Nicely done, good luck in the challenge.

the jumper
by 2mccs

Comment:
There is a lot to look at in this shot but I find myself wondering what I am supposed to look at, where should my focal point be. As I look for the focal point I get drawn into the brightness of the beam in the lower section and the darker upright on the left side instead of enjoying the shot. I love all the angles and lines I just wish there was maybe a main focal point used to drawn you into the shot. I like how the upper oval sections frames the windows in the building and maybe something like that may have been better than the entire scene.

Malay
by fotomann_forever

Comment:
Beautiful scene and subject, the framing IMO is way to tight on the head and the feet are cut off which really affects how well the shot works. I also am not a big fan of skies that have been pushed a little to far in PP. With a few tweaks this could have been an even better image. Good luck in the challenge.

Watercolored World
by wildiris

Comment:
The colors are beautiful but the crop just seems awkward to me, I really like the praying mantis and IMO maybe a little less foreground to get more attention on him may have worked better. 6

Cynthia
by bspurgeon

Comment:
Very nicely done, this is high key how it should be done. This is my pick for Blue, good luck in the challenge.

Tiffany
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
I thought this one might get scored poorly, I had to study it to see the triangle but when I looked at all the elements together there is a nicely composed triangle, really great shot and very under appreciated. I loved it!

Message edited by author 2010-09-21 19:00:55.