Almost Out of the Woods
by charmayne

Comment:
Deep greens and the arched silhouette work well in this composition. Great deep blacks. Fits the challenge topic well. The clarity of the detail is very nice.

The leafy branch in the upper right side of the frame and the single leaf on the top left are slightly distracting and you might consider removing them. Overall this is a very fine image.

Underground - Interlude
by Matthew

Comment:
Nicely captured from an interesting perspective. Fits the dark challenge topic well. The muted color with prominet reds gives the composition slightly surrealistic appearance. The leading curves are terrific. You capture the feeling of a lonely subway station exceptionally well.

You might consider copping the topmost large bright stripe from the composition. Its large size acts more as a distraction than supporting the rest of this fine composition.

At It Again
by RolandB

Comment:
Alchoholism is a 'good' dark theme. The grainy color noise seems to work in this composition. Clarity is nice. Composition and perspective are OK.

Though the color in the bottle works very well the rest of the image might better fit the dark theme if it were B&W. Perhaps even a total B&W image might be considered. B&W works because of the lack of detail in the dark garment worn and the dark background. The yellow cloth just seems to happy.

Out of the Shadows
by Jutilda

Comment:
Good dark image where B&W works well. The tonal range is good and it has very nice sharp detail. The fine detail in the center of the leaf is its strongest feature.

The detail near the edge of the big leaf appears a bit grainy and more granular than some people may like but it is not terribly bad.

Though photographically a good image viewers will have a tough time strongly relating to it and the darkness theme. Without a strong connection they will not vote it as high as they otherwise might.

Hmmm! Liquid darkness after a day's work
by p2jvr

Comment:
Colors are good and natural. Overall it is a nice image and a pleasant change from the darker themes of most of the images. The clarity of the hands and beer cans and bottles is good. Choosing to capture a toast is a great idea. It implies a fun twist on the "dark" (dark beer, that is) challenge theme.

Compositionally the wall with the flower holder may not be the best choice for a background. It has too much non-dark beer related interest that draws the viewer's attention away from the main subject. A less busy background would be worth considering.

Though the rest of the exposure is very good the white of the table cloth is overexposed and almost hurts the eye to look at. It is very distracting to the rest of the image. The spillage on the lower right looks more like dirt than the result of having a good time.

Black pieces conducted by the shadows
by greslizzz

Comment:
B&W is a good choice for the darkness challenge topic. Perspective is fine. Including the piece shadow is a nice touch. Greys are generally OK and you have a good black point set. Many images do not have good black points set in this challenge.

Compositionally there seems to be a lot of wasted space left and right of the chess pieces that could be removed from the composition.

The biggest issue with this image that will hold the score back is the focal plane. This image is focused on the far wall. A common problem with autofocus cameras is they sometimes focus where you don't want them to. That appears to be the case here. Even if done purposely most voters will think it is a focusing error. The queen, which occupies the dominent position in the frame, is not in proper focus. A confusion for the viewer is that the king, which is better focused but is located right behind the queen. The viewer has to study the image too hard to figure that out. That may have been your intention but most viewers will not "get it" if it is and score it lower because of it.

Cornered and Alone
by mesmeraj

Comment:
A curious attempt at the challenge theme. Photographically done generally well and placement of your subject near the edge of the frame is a good idea. Lighting, though in a dark place, is good and muted color in a grey place works.

The viewer is going to ask themselves questions. Why is the subject dressed the way she is? What has made her feel cornered? Why is she huddled in that particular location? These are questions that the image itself does not seem to lead the viewer to think of plausible answers.

The "thing" left of center frame and left of the girl's shoulder has such a prominent position in the frame that viewers regard it as a major element of the composition. It's relationship to the girl is unclear and therefore some voters will think of it as a distraction rather than supporting the image in a significant way.

Message edited by author 2005-06-22 02:27:08.

Fighting Daylight
by ttibby

Comment:
Certainly a subject worthy of the challenge topic. The image has no serious hot spots and the greyscales are generally good. B&W is a good choice for this subject.

The border takes up a considerable percentage of image real estate and may be considered distracting to some viewers because there is no obvious way it supports the main subject.

Technically there are a couple aspects of this image that will keep it's score lower. The image is low contrast. This is made even more pparent by your black border. You should set a black point for it or darken blacks using selective color black adjustment or channel mixer slider adjustments. Perhaps you used low cotrast on purpose. If so, it will not work with most voters.

The image is presented from the "snapshot" perspective. It appears to have been taken simply while walking by. A different perspective like ground level may have been more interesting to the viewer and connected better to the theme of being down and out. Consider a closer crop to more closely highlight the person themselves.

Nowhere to Hide
by Achinx

Comment:
Good solid black background supports the challenge theme well and the color is fine. You use DOF to highlight the main subject and draw the viewers attention.

The message of this image will be obscure at best to most voters and they will score it lower as a result. Great images often raise provocative questions in the veiwer's mind but this seems to raise questions that most viewers won't care about. They ask, "Why is the ball with the word "Hudson" on it the main subject and why should I care about it? Why is it on a ball in the first place? Why does it need a place to hide? It does not engage the viewer to want to understand why or speculate on answers.

On the technical side this is a generally well done image. Clarity of the main subject is excellent. The bright spot by the "n" is only slightly overexposed.

For added interest you might consider repositioning the ball on the rightmost rule of thirds vertical line centered on the intersection point with the lower rule of thirds horizontal line. You would remove unneeded and distracting foreground bluriness and give it a right facing appearance that is more pleasing to the human eye.

Flash!
by Cooz

Comment:
Greyscale tones and focus are good. Photographs of photographers taking pictures generally do not fare well at DPC but they have been top performers in some challenges.

Like a well told story everything in the image should tie together to a singular theme or related themes and not contain elements that do not support it. In your image the viewer that notices the rings will wonder what purpose they serve in the composition. The reversed name Nikon at the top will be a distraction for most viewers.

Some viewers may feel you are flaunting the challenge topic with this image and will vote it lower. The composition is OK but nothing really unique or special.

On the technical side there does not appear to be a true black point for this image. It is rarely a good idea to include overexposed areas in any image but I understand why you did here. It is still a technical flaw though.

Message edited by author 2005-06-22 02:20:18.