Repose
by Brin

Comment:
I am sure that this will be in the top ten.

Concerto
by Wildcard

Comment:
wow!!! only now I read that this is your photo.Congratulations!!!!! I have rated it with 10 during the challenge and I am very happy that you won this challenge. great photo and great title!

Missing Color
by FallenAngel360

Comment:
Greeting from critique club.

Hi, I see that you have a very low score for this image. most of the comments that you have are true. the composition isn't really interesting, the main flower isn't sharp and the focus is a bit far from it. the image don't seems a good image for sepia challenge, probably you could improve it with shadows and highlight, I read that you have used the camera settings for the sepia tuning probably a conversion with photoshop or other image editor should be more helpful.

for any question about this comment please contact me.

gennaro

An Intimate Moment
by albc28

Comment:
Greeting from Critique Club

Hi, I think that is a good photograph. From compositional point of view I would more space on the right. The people on the background, on the right side, is a bit distracting but probably could be used as compositional element if the cropped girls on the right would be entire(with a bit of more blur on the background). I like the pose of the models and I would that be a candid photo. the sepia tone work well in this photo.

For any question about this comment please contact me.

Gennaro

5 a day
by SoulMan1978

Comment:
Critique Club Greetings

Hi, I think that this is a good idea but with a very bad realization. The most important problem that I see (always as my personal opinion) is the light. too much on the fruits and too much strong. the colours aren't very good, not natural but this is a consequence of the light.
from compositional point of view is good.

Gennaro

P.S. if you have something to ask me please send me a personal message.

Kid Laundry Machine
by jasonlprice

Comment:
ahahahah how many big is the laudry machine?

XYZ
by gaurav

Comment:
too muche easy :)

Pond Quite Reflective
by lynnesite

Comment:
I really like this photo, I don't know if the natural frame around the (heron-cormoran?) is distracting or more probably exalts the subject but 10

Kiwi Lemon Mix
by timwest167

Comment:
eheh nice idea, but on the perfect crop of the fruits I have some doubt :) 7

afternoon ballet class
by whiteroom

Comment:
good this. nice image and colours