'all that's left is right '
by noot

Comment:
Not sure the photo matches with the text, or I am confused about things. But in any case, it's a lovely shot - I especially love the colors and the not-rule-of-thirds composition.

City Slicker Camping
by JackRyan

Comment:
Wow, impressive! I really love the humor here, not to mention that I like this photo technically.

Woody at the Wall
by GrayGhost

Comment:
Wow, amazing setup.

"Mom?"
by Jaded_Housewife

Comment:
Aww, this is yours? Awesome! Yay for this wonderful and emotional photo.

The Re-Emergence of a Giant
by tryals15

Comment:
Critique Club

As you alluded to in your comments, the lighting is very impressive here. It gives what would be a decent shot a real punch. The tones are nice and I like your choice of black and white - makes this seem like a very serene and solemn image.

I think what throws me is there is such a beautiful curve to the building... almost like a women's torso, and then looking at the bottom is sort of jarring, in comparison. Maybe it would be better, for me, if you had cropped to the point where the diagonal line of the bottom building *just* stops at the edge of the curve. That way you would eliminate both the building in the background as well as the diagonal line that contrasts so much with the curved main subject.

However, even as it is, I think this is a great shot! I wish I could see all of it on my monitor at once - I have a feeling I would like it even more. And really, the stuff about the bottom being in contrast.. it really does not take too much away from this image.

Together alone
by dippydaz

Comment:
Critique Club

I think this is a good shot and you did well with the levels and saturation. I like the colors, especially the contrast between light and shadows.

I do agree about maybe cropping differently, though. You did a great job with emphasizing the "aloneness" and I think maybe the "together" needs to be emphasized a little more with a bit of a tighter crop. But I think compositionally, the cropping isn't as weird for me as the different lines are... there are two diagonal lines made by the clouds and the sloping line of the ground - I think these three elements don't mesh as well as other shots of this type I have seen.

But regardless, I think the shot is powerful because the two people are present and clear - it gives it an impact that the same shot but without the people would not have.

Open season - ducky hunting
by digidori

Comment:
Not sure most people would, but I like the contrast and blown highlights!

..and who's not supposed to bee here!!!!!!!!!
by kawesttex

Comment:
Great colors and lighting.

floating away
by asimchoudhri

Comment:
Maybe some people won't like this since the ducks aren't prominant enough, but you definitely "included" them in your photo as the challenge description says, and this is a really lovely shot I think!

for my bestest friend
by Ecce_Signum

Comment:
Awww! Adorable idea.