The Highlighted Area
by inspzil

Comment:
Absolutely great! Fantastic colors. Excellent use of water drops. great composition. Nice crop and frame. 10.

Travel to the Pyramid
by kandyj

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club!

At a quick glance, this photo is very well shot. The composition is well executed, although I feel it might have been improved by panning the camera down a littlebit.
The oblique line of the street meeting up at the pyramid with the horizontal line created by the bridge and lights at the horizon work like a charm.
The only problem IMO is that the photo is lacking the extra little thing that would raise its interest value. As it is, it's well executed, but it's just uninspiring. Fortunately, the pyramid raises the bar a littlebit visually by breaking the horizon line and being at the juntion of the other two lines I described above maikes it even more interesting.
On a minor note, although it was obviously shot from a roof or a high platform, I do not feel it deserves to be considered a "From Above" shot. This is more a straight shoot with a smal tilt down. The camera is pointing to the horizon. But it's just my opinion on this matter.

In short: very well executed. Nice night shot. Good composition. Unfortunately uninspiring visually. 6

Keep up the good work.

The Art of Bread
by mbardeen

Comment:
Greetings from the CRITIQUE CLUB!

Watching this photo, many things come to mind. It is clear that its subject is right on par with the challenge's theme. Most obviously, you wanted to show the art of cooking in all its splendor by presenting this visually very tasteful home made bread. The intention was very good.
Unfortunately, the photo is simply uninspiring and most probably because of the lack of inspiration in the first place.
Such a nice bread deserves all the attention it can get! :-)
In technical terms:
Visually, the lighting as it is is very flat. The use of a very low F-Stop could have helpted in creating a nice depth of field and emphasize the visual quality of the bread by isolating it from its surrounding, but even though we see the background leaves in a soft off focus, the image still looks kind of flat- most probably due to the choice of angle used and the light source. The composition and choice of angle could have been revised to find the best and more appropriate framing/omposition to present this subject in a more original way. The blue/white/purple cloth on the right is very distracting and doesn't seem to fit in the photo. The leaves are distracting as well.
Maybe a close up on the bread would have made it more interesting. Or simply putting it in a different setup.

This photo is the basic example of the high level of difficulty encountered when shooting a simple subject: the simpler the subject, the more the photographer needs to work hard on creating an interesting ambiance (lighting, setting, angle and composition) to reach the viewer.

Your "Photographer's Comment" indicates to me that you were aware about the basic problems of this photograph. My suggestion would be to listen to your instincs and to use these thoughts to challenge yourself. When you feel your photograph is "pretty cliche and you think you couldn't come up with anything else good", my suggestion to you is to either push the enveloppe further to surpass yourself, or simply put your mind into finding something else either by yourself, or with the help of friends during a conversation or a brainstorm.

Challenge yourself.

4/10

Kitchen Vortex
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Fantastic composition. Crisp as it can be. Great choice of color! Very dynamic. One of the best in this challenge. I think it deserved a better rank than it got. Keep it up!

Life from above
by Geocide

Comment:
Greetings from the CRITIQUE CLUB!

At first glance, this photo is intriguing and interesting visually. The fact that it's very hard to tell what the subjet is is not a problem at all and the photo can be seen and interpreted on many levels which brings this photo in the abstract category. Its composition is very well done. The lines pointing to the orange circle works extremely well. The crop is excellent and the two larger sections on the right really add something to the visual quality of the photo. The orange color on blue is interesting as well.

Shot at a lower ISO would have surelly helped to reduce the high grain especially noticable in the orange and shadows on the white areas. Also, the photo doesn't seem to meet with the challenge. There is no indication that it was shot from above. The blue seems to be the sky and therefore indicates that it was shot from bellow. Wether ot not it was the case, the simple fact that as a viewer there is not way to know is enough to conclude that it doesn't meet with the challenge.

Original shot. Very nice composition. Excellent effort. Would get a 7 on its own when not considering the challenge theme. Rates under 5 when considering the challenge.

Beer above all!
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Greetings from the CRITIQUE CLUB.

The photo has an intriguing quality to it. It's hard to tell what the subject is. Without the title, I must say I probably would not have guessed about the bottle of beer. My first impression was that it was an ink bottle or something. Never the less, this shouldn't be a problem with this kind of imagery.

The choice of color is interesting. The table lines and textures adds to the visual quality of the photo. The blur at the top of the bottle is somewhat distracting. The hard flash seems to bring out nice shines on the bottle surface and the shadow is not bothering. The composition seems a bit off to the left, but it's not distracting.

The only problem I find with this photo is it's lack of punch. It just doesn't seem to provide a high enough level of interest visually. Although it does meet with the challenge, the fact that it was shot from above doesn't actually add to the feeling of the composition. The simplicity of a composition is actually something hard to achieve because its subject and lighting has to have a very high level of visual impact to affect the viewer. In this case, the subject is plain and the ovarall impact is quite low. Adding beer drops on the table with light reflections might have helped- or any other detail to enhance the visuals. Unfortunately, as it is, it's a technically ok photo with a less than average visual interest. 5
Keep it up.

Go On...I DARE YA!! or DPhrustration
by dacrazyrn

Comment:
Hi. I think you're going to be asked this question a lot: wy is the 9 on the Roll in the photo??? Does your subject imply that you dare us to give it a 9/10? Or is it a comment about a past rating you reeived? Or is it just there to make us ask questions? In any case, I find it extremely sad to see that 9 in there because otherwise your photo would truely merit a 9 or 10. Unfortunately, the 9 bugs me so much in this photo, I can't give it more than 7 (and I was tempted to lower it to 6). On the other hand, extremely well taken photograph. Excellent dramatic lighting that support the emotion in the subject's face. Excellent cropping. Excellent color.

Good Clean Fun
by connie

Comment:
Superb! A perfect photo. 10

laptop
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
BRavo Mr. Dude! :-) Si près d'un deuxième ruban! :-)

Collateral Damage
by nds

Comment:
Bravo! Excellent framing. I love your square cropping that goes so well with the squared windows. Fantastic location. Excellent color. 10/10 [the only ten in my book this week]