Flight
by naplesmusc

Comment:
Technical: great contrast, great coloring, nice composition
Creativity: it's a bird with the water...not too creative, but the fact that you actually have the bridge in the background helps greatly!
Personal Opinion: i like it, it's not the average bird in challenges...but it is still pretty sweet!
Score: 10

Ocracoke Sunset
by agrimace

Comment:
Technical: the color contrast (imo) could be a little more, having three items in a line is nice (sun, boat, and whatever is in the water), the contast seems ok...the water is a little dull but that's ok...
Creativity: if the boat was a little more off centered i would really like it...
Personal Opinion: i still think it's a great photo! a little more contrast in coloring would help me out!
Score: 6

Ferris Wheel
by dynamomomof2

Comment:
Technical: The composition is good, the coloring is great. the only thing is the areas that should be focused aren't. not sure if you used a tripod, but if you didn't consider either that or a fence post or something!

Creativity: it probably isn't the most creative image...but it also isn't one that i have seen! so i will give you a couple extra points there!

Personal Opinion: not a bad image, could use a little more cleaning up or practice, but I still like it!

Score: 5

Flying Solo
by philup

Comment:
Technical: Great focus, nice contrast and levels, great back lighting
Creative: Na, probably not too creative...but I really like the sepia tone you did! that's what makes it different from others!
Personal Opinion: I still love it...a little off-centered which helps!
Score: 10

Harvest
by h2

Comment:
Technical: wonderful composition and coloring. The lower half of the sky seems a little blown out but i don't think it's too bad!
Creativity: it might not be the most creative image, but I do think what helps with this is the other bails in the background.
Personal Opinion: I like the image, i am mutual on the border...i don't think it was necessary, but it does look nice!
Score: 9

Las Vegas
by Nigel

Comment:
That's so intersting to see the improvement! Wow in only 3 years....Vegas...an everchanging city, proved once again! Great shot!

Determination
by bvoi

Comment:
Technical: great composition and coloring, the black background really helps, the focus seems to be alittle off...can't quite tell what you are focusing on.
Creativity: because you focused on a closer image of a bird, i think the creativity area deserves a bump
Personal Opinion: the title helps in my opinion...
Score: 8

In the Marsh
by fotomann_forever

Comment:
Technical: the colors are amazing, the composition is great because it isn't quite centered...
Creativity: it might not be too creative in the fact that there are alot of landscape type of photos, but the fact that you have many different landscape elements is what makes this photo stand out from the others.
Personal Opinion: i love the softness of the photo with the bright bold colors of nature...absolutely beautiful!!!
Score: 10

amish corner
by chele

Comment:
Technical: i think the idea is great, if the chairs weren't so centered in the frame it would be even better! the coloring is great, dodging and burning works well...
Creativity: it difintely is out of the norm...which i love!!!
Personal Opinion: it's one of those photos that makes you wonder who sits there and the work they might have put into each and every chair...
Score: 7

Old Soul
by mandyturner

Comment:
Technical: love the coloring, composition, pose and lighting. Seems like the white is a little blown out but it's ok!
Creativity: the saturation is what makes this photo fit the name! great job.
Personal Opinion: she looks like a doll that may grandma used to have sitting on the shelf...too cute...
Score: 7