Pick On Someone Your Own Size!
by whitetiger

Comment:
The people (and staircases) provide a sense of scale that makes this shot immensely more effective. This shot made me think about how I can't even imagine a living one of those suckers.

Jeni's Etude
by sagestudio

Comment:
This was a good choice for a multi-image shot, because the right and left side shots are good shots, but without a context they would be hard to identify for someone not familar with the harp. However, the middle shot provides that context, and therefore makes the other shots more effective. Good work. 7

$peedVision
by RiderGal

Comment:
I like the tight crops on these. I think the result is more compelling than if they had been more revealing shots of the cars. Lets see how my identification skills are, I'd guess top to bottom: Lamborghini (Diablo), Jag (not sure about that one), and Ferrari (F50). I guess I'll see how I did after the challenge. 8

Downtown
by ursula

Comment:
The top left image looks over cropped (blurry, low resolution). The top left, and bottom images are somewhat interesting, although not particularly drawing. However, the top right image is excelent. The curves and lines work quite effectively in it, and I think it would be better as a stand alone image than this is as a multi-image.

In the Blink of an Eye
by StevePax

Comment:
The colors here look washed out and the eye isn't in sharp focus. The concept has some potential, but the presentation lacks oomph. I'd have tried different angles and probably more dramatic lighting, as this ends up rather drab.

Dream Cars
by orussell

Comment:
Heh.. how did a toyota celica get in there with two porsches?

Know your beneficial insects: Flies in Green, Gold and Blue
by Budweezer

Comment:
The top images would look better if they were the same height. It kills the balance and symmetry by making the right side jut out into the bottom shot.

Oriental Breeze
by bruster54

Comment:
I really like the center frame and how it shows up in minimalist ways only, however, it doesn't really fit into the tone of this sequence very well, since the other two show up very clearly and strongly. I think putting the center shot against a white background would have created an interesting contrast with the other two shots, but still maintained the same tone as the other shots. 7

Thoroughbred Park
by RLS

Comment:
Well, it's an interesting image. The top and bottom shots frame the middle shot pretty well. The effect here is effectively applied, and applicable to the shot, as it is intended to display motion. So I'd say this is more than just photoshop for the sake of photoshop, however, I wouldn't really say this is a photograph so much as a piece of art that used a photograph as it's basis, so I'm not as inclined to score it as highly in a photography contest. Good luck. 5

DPChallenge Logo on Wooden Trash Bin
by orussell

Comment:
It's somewhat more unique than just a plain logo, but in fact it becomes less clearly visable than a plain logo, and the new texture doesn't really connect in any way with the site or make this a more appealing design. The beveled, drop shadowed url is a bit over processed I think. Plain black text would probably have been more effective.