windy city river
by parrothead

Comment:
5 - Good. Make a good postcard. Criticism; difficult, as so much detail is lost this small, bet it looks great 'wall size'. Perhaps a slight straightening of the sign in 2, not sure, might just be the angle. It is in a sense a 'personal' type shot or as I said, postcard/commercial like.

U3
by Artan

Comment:
4 - Good potential. Good contrast control. Criticism; perhaps either a 'zooming' in 'series' may have worked better (if this is the same 'ewe'), or else just different 'poses' - balancing it out, or creating more of a 'flow' effect, may have made this better in my opinion.

Window to Blue
by SandyP

Comment:
6 - Very nice, focus and coloring are very good. Criticism; whilst no 'expert' in triptychs, to me, this would be better if the cuts/crops flowed 'smoothly' from panel to panel, either by a realignment or by a 'deletion' of that space - if that makes sense. In my opinion, this is one of the 'single split photos' that the separation/panelling/framing via triptych, has worked well and enhances the shot.

Picks of the Season
by GentleSoul

Comment:
4 - Nice and 'soft', coloring and 'focus'. Criticism; whilst I think the frame color suits the background colors I am not sure it suits the subjects. Overall, while nice and 'clean', this lacks 'something' in my opinion, maybe just a richer coloring or uniform crop, may have made it better, not sure.

Pinecones
by Elaine

Comment:
6 - Nice. Criticism; seems a little 'hazy', but could be something lost in the resize, not sure, so a little more vivid in color, if possible, contrast dependent, may have made this better in my opinion. Nice and 'simple'. Also may have worked well at 640x640, if possible.

Physalis
by mrmorris

Comment:
4 - Like the potential but, criticism; would have packed more punch in color I think, especially at this size, but I understand the concept you were going for.

Mine.....All.....Mine
by notbiscuit

Comment:
3 - Good concept. Criticism; the perspective/angle does not reach the potential I see in these shots. Perhaps getting closer (might mean slowly), or in front, could have captured more 'feel' for this 'story'. The toning doesn't work very well here, especially at this size and the focus doesn't seem sharp enough, but perhaps you lost some in the resize.

Another day in Paradise
by Jean

Comment:
7 - Very nice, and simple, works well. Criticism; not sure, just seems it needs a little 'lift' somewhere, not sure how or where, be it colors/toning, outer frame, don't know. Of course, it may just be the small size/restrictions, which I have taken into consideration.

The Wedding
by NekoNita

Comment:
6 - Good concept, well done if this is original. All nice shots. Criticism; like to see more detail in at least one frame, obviously preferably the center one, but perhaps you lost a lot in the resize. 1 & 3 do not seem to be cropped uniformly, which may be intentional, but in my opinion, would have looked better if they were, and it were 'balanced' better.

The Artist
by annah

Comment:
5 - Good concept, nice bold colors. Criticism; maybe a little too saturated, or it could be that the black frame enhances the colors more so perhaps a different color choice of framing, not sure. Not sure on the thinner middle frame, maybe more 'fore space' in all and more vertical, who knows.