Odd Birds
by Germaine

Comment:
8 - Good. Two for one. Criticism; not much, maybe slightly tighter crop, with the birds top right and the face more centered, may have made this even better, not sure.

The 6th Sentinel
by Rikki

Comment:
7 - Very nice. Good colors. Criticism; difficult, especially for the Challenge (as you've obviously centered the '6th'), but like to see the interesting pattern on the petals more, so maybe a slightly different crop. A little sharper too, albeit difficult, may have made this even better. Not sure on the white frame.

Love comes in pairs!
by gaeali

Comment:
8 - Good shot. Excellent colors and contrast control. Nice fairly simple background. Criticism; not much, maybe a little more space on the right, not sure. Up to 8 from 7.

Tale of Four Tails
by jenesis

Comment:
7 - Nice. Criticism; a little sharper if possible on the seedheads(?) would have made this better in my opinion. Maybe a slightly sharper (ground up) angle, incorporating the tips more too, not sure.

Six Meets Six
by coolhar

Comment:
7 - Good. Criticism; difficult, maybe a different composition or crop. Good action shot, would like to see a little more context though, but then you'd lose the 'impact' likely so not sure.

Two - Migration Together
by notesinstones

Comment:
8 - Very nice. Criticism; just sharper on the ducks if possible 'somehow', more definition on them, including colors. Nice overall 'feel'.

Identity Crisis
by aznym

Comment:
7 - Good. Criticism; maybe a slightly tighter crop at the fore, giving the 'cone' more height may have made this better in my opinion. Maybe also aiming for more 'symmetry' overall compositionally, not sure. It's dark, but I think that adds an element to this that helps it. Not sure on the thick frame.

Even for 100 years
by lilcrazyfuzzy

Comment:
8 - Like the concept and angle/depth and colors. Criticism; a little sharper on the equation would have made this even better in my opinion. Maybe a tweak of the lighting, not sure, giving more 'feel' to the paper. Nice overall feel to this shot. edit:formula to equation

Message edited by author 2005-12-01 05:18:45.

Is anyone watching?
by ladpupmoe

Comment:
6 - Like it, poor dog, like the matching cards. Criticism; looks 'snapshottish', so if you had the chance, maybe a sharper angle, different lighting, or just something to create the 'illusion' would have made this better in my opinion.

Bored of Education
by scalvert

Comment:
9 - Very Funny. Thanks for the laugh. Criticism; not much at all, I like the whole set up, composition colors, background, pose, etc. Maybe to really nit-pick the book placed differently but trivial. Seems slight issues with the green on the wallpaper(?), but could be my monitor. Ok, maybe she could have something 'written' on the paper for added effect, but again minor. Well done. Up to 9 from 8. edit:typo & congratulations

Message edited by author 2005-12-08 18:51:35.