Tiny Heart Beats
by lmhr

Comment:
Beautiful photography. Excellent lighting and skin tones. Lovely and unique take on the challenge.

Magic Flute
by adine

Comment:
Hmm...very interesting photo. I assume you mean for the smoke to represent air that passes through the flute that makes the sound as it's being played. However, no one is playing it, therefore making it magic I suppose. I really like the effect of the swirls of smoke, the lighting and your origionality.

Sizzling Morning Campfire
by DougPaz

Comment:
Very good idea!! Just looking at this, I can hear the sizzle. I love campfire cooking. Great detail of the bubbles in the bacon grease. I think, though, that it's a little overexposed, especially on the bacon that isn't cooked all the way yet. Doesn't really make it look very appealing.

Sound Waves
by Toddh

Comment:
Very nice idea. I think I would have liked to see more focus on the water. Plus, I think there was a little too much lighting from above. The reflective light is a distraction. However, the concept of your photo is great.

Sound of crushing waves
by pitsaman

Comment:
Yes, this meets the challenge in my opinion. Not only the waves, but the sounds of the birds flying overhead. There is just something about this photo that doesn't seem make me say WOW though. Perhaps a closer crop and a little boost in the saturation to make the waves more dramatic and bring more color out. Just a thought. Good luck in the challenge.

Snap, Crackle and Pop
by mariomel

Comment:
Very good idea and nicely done. I like your set-up and the colors. Good detail on the rice krispies. I also really like how you did your border. I think your picture would have been even better, though, had the background been blocked somehow between the cereal box and the cup to avoid the light reflections. They are a distraction. My score = 7 Good luck in the challenge.

Surf
by JPR

Comment:
This picture seems to portray action more than sound in my opinion. Therefore, as an action shot, it is done well. It is nicely focused and I like the reflection of the surfer in the water. I'm not sure as I like the over-exposed look. I would like to have seen some detail of the waves on the right.

Sound of Freedom
by marinajoe

Comment:
That is a beautiful picture of Liberty! The lighting and framing are absolutely perfect. Shows great detail to. I like your take on the challenge. I wish you the best of luck in the challenge. 10 in my book

Not so loud
by Crafty Sue

Comment:
Oh, yes...I can relate. Those kind of beings CAN make a lot of noise. I like the action of the hands. Nice family snapshot and looks as if they had a lot of fun posing for it. I think it would have portrayed noise just a little better if the kids would of had their faces more toward the camera to see their expressions.

Vroom Vroom Vroom Vroom
by Gotchya

Comment:
If I'm not mistaking, this is the exhast system of the car. Wouldn't the vroom sound would come from the engine? Also, something about the colors in this picture just doesn't seem right. I do like the refections of the pipes. It is well focused and does make a somewhat abstract-y photo.