File
by ruffian

Comment:
I thought that this was a winner.

I gave it high marks for thinking out of the box, and for everything else a good pix demands.

Nice job, too bad a bug and a flower took the ribbons.

Beyond the Circle
by f-32

Comment:
We all know that this is a "Circle" challenge. Disappointed in the title.

Comp nice, nice lighting, interesting pose, b&w nice, sharp, color needs work, flat in fact, overall a good job

The Ring
by quzailan

Comment:
Nice idea, excellent comp, excellent lighting, pro quality I may add, blacks and whites great, dof great, great lines, original title, overall a very good job.....1!

SIKE!!!!!

Crop Circles
by SJCarter

Comment:
Very nice idea.

I appreciate the originality of the titleing, nice touch.

IMO the comp is ok, the dof excellent, whites need work, blacks ok, mountain too soft, lighting fg ok, lighting bg ok but that mountain again, sky a bit blown, overall a nice pix.

Sleeping Fairy Princess
by mystical_princess

Comment:
NIce job anyway.

Great Stuff.

The only thing is, I know this is a fantasy, but what she is lying on doesn't sell me.

Other than that........fricken nice job!

Revenge On Authority ... Got A Match ?
by Coley

Comment:
Coley?Inede?

I truly love what you did here. You have a great imagination, and wit, but for the challenge, I am stumped.

Comp excellent, talent blocking great, story telling excellent, b&W's great, good motion, lines are there, but not leading IMO. Overall this is a great thing youv'e done, but not for this challenge.

Leading Lines to Power Your Home
by bandit

Comment:
We all know that this is a "Leading Lines" challenge. If by saying "To power your home" only gives a differant perspective, and makes the titleing stronger.

Nice color, crop needs work buy not bad, nice sillouette, nice lighting, nice dof, overall nice

This is a Leading Line
by yeoua

Comment:
We all know that this is a \"Leading Lines\" challenge. IMO, you could of done better on the title.

NIce use of props, beautiful b&w's, Some thing funny with the thumbs edging, maybe to much sharpening, geat lighting, nice texture, overall very out of the box, nice job

Leading Lines
by UNCLEBRO

Comment:
We all know that this is a "Leading Lines" challenge. IMO, I think you could of done better with a differant title. The opportunity that you passed on, to make something truly yours by giving it a name, by actually visuallizing something more original saddens me.

Great comp,nice dof, nice movement, great lines, blacks ok, whites need work, silouette nice, overall very good.

Lines Leading Nowhere
by GeneralE

Comment:
We all know that this is a "Leading Lines" challeng. By just saying "Nowhere" gives a differant perspective, and makes the picture that much more stronger.

nice comp, nice dof, nice lines, blacks good, whites need work, lighing sillouette nice, nice idea, overall good.