First Base
by L1

Comment:
No further comment is need......................10

Shot Gun Smoke Ring
by sofap

Comment:
Don't like the shape of the frame. 9

Raindrops
by om10

Comment:
Meet description of challenge............10
Meets definition of Minimalism.............10
Technical.............................................10
Artistic...................................................6

Average score......................................9

Hidden
by Mr_Pants

Comment:
Meets description of challenge............5 becuase the background is so busy and demands your attention before you see the animal...
Meets the definition of Minimalism.........5 the image speaks about the bushes in a more direct manor
Technical................................................6
Artistic.....................................................6
Average score...........................................................5

Symbolism
by JPR

Comment:
Meets description of challenge.....10
Meets description of Minimalism.....7
Technical.........................................10
Artisctic...........................................7

Average score.................................8

Solitary Tree
by artvet

Comment:
Beautiful image, 6

Negative Energy
by DustDevil

Comment:
Some technical problems and as far as I'm concerned the photo meets the description of the challenge and the definition of Minimalism. I don't believe all art needs to be perfect in the execution. 10

untitled
by amjlt

Comment:
I hate scoring this image so low because I like it very much.....Seems to be technical issues concerning sharpness and clarity....I don't know if it is noise or artifacts but I am sure you can fix them up. Nice image though it show sensitivity to the subject and speaks to the viewer....at least me.

Last Wave
by Zoomdak

Comment:
Image seems to need alot of work to make it clearer. If you took care of the technical problem this image would be something I would like to hang on my walls because I am a surfer and can relate to what you are capturing here

Surrounded by Beauty
by JScho

Comment:
Meets challenge description........0
Meets definition of Minimalism........7
Technical....................................8
Artistic........................................7

Averge score...............................6