In Memory of Syd Barrett - Wish You Were Here
by Blackbox

Comment:
I like the reflection in the guitar a lot. There seems to be a yellow color cast to the photo, though. Also, there's something about the crop that's not totally pleasing to me - it doesn't really comport with the law of thirds. Finally, there are some distracting elements in the background (carpet and something on the wall.

A Momentary Lapse of Reason
by carotop111

Comment:
I'm not sure how this picture fits the title.

"My hands felt just like two balloons" Comfortably Numb, The Wall, 1979
by tate

Comment:
This is the most clever photo I've seen so far... how'd you get the "hands" to float in the air like that? String? Throw them? That having been said, There are a couple of problems w/ the photo. I feel it has been oversharpened b/c there is - I don't know what it's called - the little dots of noise in the sky. Also, the waves look a little "squared off," and the water is lighter in color between the legs, which is probably a residual from the sharpening. Finally, the picture gives me the impression of being tilted, even though the horizon is approximately straight, because the land is at an angle.

"Grab That Cash With Both Hands . . ." - Money
by sammy_stecchino

Comment:
I thought I had already commented on this picture, but it came up again so maybe it didn't accept my first comment.

The model looks too happy, imo, or actually the wrong kind of happy, for the mood of this picture - like he's part of an after school special or on mood enhancers. I think it would have been better with a slightly crazed look or something. Just my opinion, though.

"I've Been Mad For F#&*ing Years, Absolutely Years, Been Over The Edge For Yonks..."
by Wildcard

Comment:
I like this photo a lot - my only complaint is the lighter area in the bottom right.

Astronomy Domine
by David1411

Comment:
It wouldn't accept my comment a minute ago so let me try again (sorry if you get two).

There's a lot of noise - NeatImage would probably have helped. I would also have cropped out the tree on the righthand side, and possibly have cropped the bottom a bit more b/c the reflections are distracting. Finally, I think it would have been nicer if the contrast were boosted a bit.

Goodbye Blue Sky
by fordmanf1

Comment:
I don't personally like IR shots. Also seems a tad soft. Did you USM?

Money (The Dark Side of the Moon)
by Claya

Comment:
I don't love the flare, especially around the arm.

Have a cigar
by asimchoudhri

Comment:
The white at the top left and right is a bit distracting - it keeps us from seeing the sides of the box.

Goodbye Blue Sky
by jjbeguin

Comment:
I'm confused about the black on the righthand side. Also, the darks are very dark and you lose definition towards the bottom of the stairs, which may have been what you were going for, but since you can see detail again beyond that point it wasn't all that effective. If you were implying loss of detail as you go down it might have been best to crop while in the dark part at the bottom.