Cottage For Sale
by gsal

Comment:
Very pretty. It feels like an image that would be in a story book. Looks almost like a face in the lower right window, behind a bottle. I'm so glad you chose to frame with the fence at the bottom and I love the processing.

The Gymnast
by bobdaveant

Comment:
This is such a beautiful shot, Bob. I like the motion very much and the green on her shirt really puts the viewer's eye right on her - I bet you're proud of her and she of you (great photographer dad and all that)!

Springhouse Window
by bumpus

Comment:
Wish it didn't have the brown border. I hate it when people comment on borders because it's such a personal thing, but in this case, it does draw my eye away from the picture, so I feel it's worth mentioning. Otherwise, the concept with the window is pretty good.

Derelict
by Jutilda

Comment:
Ooooh, I like this one! The broken windows and that old structure (silo?) in the background are so interesting. I also like the way you've put an uneven amount of the wall space on either side. Too bad that power line pole is in the background, though - but I guess it would've been a bit much to move for a stupid challenge, eh? :-)

Antique Bulb and Lamp
by Kathyc

Comment:
Even though both objects, the background and the lamp, are attractive in their own way, there's too much distraction because both are ornate - especially the background. I think this is a beautiful lamp and would love to see it presented in a more straight way and with a plain background.

Old Fish Shack
by KOKOCAT

Comment:
I'd love to see this in black and white. The textures and lines are really interesting, with the wood and the stones in the background.

The Slide Rule
by BakerBug

Comment:
Nice with the spotlight! This looks like a stock shot - the shadow adds interest. (hey, and aren't these complementary colors, too?!) Good job.

Forever 7:29
by dahved

Comment:
What a beautiful cloth this is! I think the watch definitely says "something old", but I do feel the image is too busy due to the fact that both the watch and the cloth are relatively ornate.

Argoflex (Old Technology) and Old Doll
by digitaldave

Comment:
The doll is REALLY creative for this type of image! Kind of a too-tight crop on the sides and too little on the top, in my opinion, but maybe this is just how you wanted it. I like the colors.

Old Rock
by mrwaffles989

Comment:
I'd like to see this rotated counter-clockwise a little. The trees in the upper left take away from the waterfall, which stands out more than the rock. The focus on the water is really nice, as are the tones in the sky. I'd really like to see the rock highighted more, if that is what your subject is.