Piece of Heaven
by chipuc

Comment:
Too much shadow to gather what piece o heaven you are referring to.

( 1 )

Dribble
by PGerst

Comment:
While possibly an adorable image to yourself and family, not an appealing image to me (even with a baby on the way). Lots of noise in the reds.

( 1 )

Up the Down Staircase
by Cantique

Comment:
My God this is Escheresch!
10!

You Guys Can't Do This
by cloudsme

Comment:
Crop factor width, makes the model look stretched out. A narrower crop to fit her body style or a different pose to fit into a landscape view of her pregnancy would have helped this image out greatly. The dark areas seem to have lost all detail in the shadow, but otherwise a very nice capture, good focus, great contrast of light and dark. Does not project challenge well without title.

( 5 )

ready boys ?
by idp

Comment:
Concept Good
Nice focus, good dynamic light.
Glove detail may have been lost through neatimage.

( 5 )

Battle Won
by Ken

Comment:
great concept, interesting angle, good use of select desat.
Grey tone however leaves this image somewhat flat.

( 5 )

Size Isn't Everything
by riot

Comment:
Too much space between the players. Oversharpening left his nose looking like a set of stairs. Too much shadow, not enough back light on the top, coming down.
Otherwise, great focus, good concept.


( 5 )

Evolution Revolution
by idnic

Comment:
Great concept, murky shadows and lack of back lighting on left leave the image flat. It directly takes away from the punch line. She should have more space in front of her and be well-defined against the background.

( 5 )

Women & Maps
by lahulfman

Comment:
This one challenges me. It feels off center/titled, but the motion blur and gold tone may be an illusion in the making. Nice expressions and framing.

( 5 )

SOAP vs SPORTS
by InDots

Comment:
Image concept fair. Stark image, the negative space with the white rope detracts from the impact. Otherwise a great clean image, focus spot on, nice tonality.

( 6 )