Railway Essentials
by Konador

Comment:
Well, normally I hate noise/grain but in this shot it works very well with the subdued colouring. Nice job and excellent choice.

They Were my Brothers
by Artyste

Comment:
Nice lighting.

Coney Island's Best
by Cutter

Comment:
Cool, I am not a fan at all of selective desat but here it works very well, one of the best shots in the challenge as I am concerned.

Posts
by tyrkinn

Comment:
Barnafoss? I like the colours and sharpness but not terribly fond of the composition, IMHO it needs a foreground.

�ááááfram ísland!

Fairyland
by heida

Comment:
Nice, I love the subdued colours and the "mysteriousness" of this shot, great job, one of the best in the challenge IMHO.

Weathered
by JayWalk

Comment:
If I may be honest I think I would have liked it more if the whole shot had been b/w or in colour, this selective desaturation doesn´t appeal to me personally and also draws the attention to the sky instead of the windmill wich is presumably the connection to the theme "wooden". Having said that though I still think this is above average in this challenge, I like the composition.

Lonely Park Bench
by deapee

Comment:
Nice scene, I like the composition but this shot has too much halo for my taste, in particular around the bench and also it´s a bit dark for my taste but I like everything else about it, 7 from me.

Welcome To My Dream Space
by flip89

Comment:
Clever use of a fisheye, I like the composition. It looks a bit flat though, maybe some more contrast would improve it?

Water Logged
by spydr

Comment:
Nice, I like the framing, the 2:1 panorama crop works well here.

portal
by visaksen

Comment:
I for one would have liked to see the surroundings about this portal, as it is not very interesting as it is right now. Also I believe this shot would improve if you had used a polarizer to make the sky more dramatic and there is a small dust spot almost in the dead center of the frame. In short I like this shot but due to all the reasons I just named it´s only an average shot in this challenge for me, 5 from me.