The Classic Ladies III
by 777STAN

Comment:
Nice colors in the shot, think it is a bit too tightly fitted in the frame though, I would have preferred it if you either had taken a sligthly wider shot and had more space around the car or just taken a closeup of it, it´s just to "cramped" for lack of a better word.

Mick Fanning (AUS)
by gliphix

Comment:
I have a feeling this will do nicely in the challenge, great image, nothing really I can fault in it except I have seen better so "only" an 8 from me :D

Living his dream
by PeterPic

Comment:
Sorry but I am not a fan of selective desat and I can tell you I would have voted this shot higher if it were in full color but that´s just me, we all have different tastes fortunately. 5 from me.

Stark Refections
by JEFFJSB

Comment:
Dig the minimalistic approach, gave it a 7.

Fly
by ergates

Comment:
Not a bad moment you caught there but two things that would have vastly improved it in my opinion.

1. Having no face of the player leads to me not connecting to it, get no emotion off the subject.

2. The vantage point, looking down upon the player isn´t working here. Nice to break the rules of not always shooting in the same level as the subject but here not really working for me.

5 from me.

poison earth
by saintaugust

Comment:
Sorry but I voted a 3 for this image, mainly cause of the coloring in this image that really doesn´t agree with me and the lack of image quality, just thought you deserved an explanation for the low vote.

Grandpa's Tractor
by mikkiowens

Comment:
I can promise you will score better if you make the most of the allowed 640 pixles.

Before the storm
by silverscreen

Comment:
Dramatic sky and nice colors but I mainly fault this image for not really having a subject, my eye wanders all over and doesn´t really stop anywhere. Not a bad shot by a long way though but not really to my taste... gave it a 6.

Settle into Fall
by adine

Comment:
How wierd is that! The DOF makes me believe the bench is a miniature, nice work on fooling the eye, dig the colos too. Did you use a tilt shift lens? 7 from me.

Autumn 2006
by justine

Comment:
Well exposed and all that but I personally just don´t really see a subject here in this shot, my eye wanders all over the frame and doesn´t stop anywhere, ended up giving it a 5.