"My hands felt just like two balloons" Comfortably Numb, The Wall, 1979
by tate

Comment:
Nice idea and pretty well executed, kindof dislike the image quality, specifially the color noise in the clouds and sand and the strong sharpening halo around the guy, that made me knock off a point but this still scored a 6 from me.

Goodbye Blue Sky
by fordmanf1

Comment:
I kindof feel this image could have been very strong but just somehow the composition feels a bit off, like I am only looking at the right half of a whole picture and also the post processing could have had a stronger, clearer crisper look to it, it´s a little too flat for my taste.

"Point Me at the Sky" Pink Floyd 1968
by tmhalling

Comment:
A very slight nitpick about the blown out area in the middle, to me I just see a hole there but it´s really nothing I am going to let bother me, this shot is good and got a 7 from me, I like the silhouette and especially the composition.

Mother, do you think they'll drop the bomb?
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Yo Tim, what´s up :)

Shine On You Crazy Diamond
by Twig

Comment:
Well this would have been a nice shot but the image quality is pretty poor, it would have needed to be clearer, more contrasty with sharper colors and better lighting to grab my attention, sorry. Also, including the green in the lower right corner really doesn´t help and would never fly in a real advertisement for a ring as it only draws attention away from it. Sorry but as it is I voted this a 3 but fix the lighting and image quality and you might be on to something.

The Thin Ice (The Wall 1979)
by btuck

Comment:
Nice sports shot but I really can´t see how this relates to the challenge if you would strip this photo of it´s title so I deducted a point for that. Dig the slight motion and out of focus player in the back but dislike the placement of the judge, he is so dominant in the composition he just draws my eye away from the player in focus.

Any Colour You Like - Duck Side of the Moon
by Pixelstate

Comment:
I kindof like this shot, very cool lighting but a bit too busy with all those ducks overlaying like that, my eye really doesn´t find a one spot to rest on. That said though, one of the best in the challenge and an 8 from me, hope you do well with it.

Dark side of the Moon
by B74A

Comment:
I gotta say I dislike those brances in the lower right corner, at least the fact that they are out of focus, they really do nothing for me other than pull my attention away from the moon.

"Waiting For Worms"
by Artan

Comment:
I have a feeling I would have liked this better in color, also I don´t find thie vantage point of the bird the best, I would have preferred to be looking it straight on and not be ogling it´s butt :)

Shine On, You Crazy Light Bulb
by imagineklp

Comment:
Sorry but I voted this a 3, It´s too flat contrast wise and uninteresting to appeal to me, just thought you should know why I votet so low.