Into Pieces
by phatphoto

Comment:
Well frankly I don´t fint the subject all that interesting, maybe a more macro approach would fix that. 5

ONIONS
by roby21112

Comment:
Well not bad but I have to put a ? about the processing here, looks like you neat imaged the heck out of this one since there is so little detail left in the faces of the guys and looks like the onions on the table were severely overexposed and then brought back in raw conversion. Also some strong artefacting in their clothes, mostly in the shadow areas. My suggestion would have to keep the noise in and make this black and white, that would eliminate the attention going to the red and yellow parts of the photos and be more about the guys and I find noise/grain quite acceptable in B/W. Sorry but cause of the image quality/post processing and the snapshottish look of this image I voted it a 4.

Nativity Scene
by faery

Comment:
Pretty good shot, would have liked to see a little bit more of the actual environment though, like a wider shot showing also their house and not just them standing in the doorway but like I said, a pretty good shot.

Where even the stones are laughing at you
by e301

Comment:
Sorry but this shot´s DOF doesn´t agree with me. The composition draws my eye towards the backround and fog to the out of focus areas and not the foreground, I would have opted for infinity focus here.

don't jump
by skewsme

Comment:
Well frankly I find this image a bit too busy for my taste, that tree in front of the house just bothers me and I didn´t notice the cat till after about 15-20 seconds of viewing, just didn´t get the title. Sorry but something to make it simpler, like losing that tree or some selective blurring or burning would have definately gotten a higher score from me, this got a 4.

Small Comfort
by scarbrd

Comment:
Fits the challenge certainly, think I would have voted this higher with better processing though, like with higher contrast and more desaturated or black and white but nice shot, 6 from me.

Brown Never Looked So Good
by JawnyRico

Comment:
First of all, nice looking lady :) Well lighting is pretty good, composition too and well pretty much nothing that I can see wrong with this shot except for one big issue, and that is the focus lying slightly in front of her eyes so they are a bit out of focus, take better care when focusing at 1.8 aperture and you should be all set. Also I personally would have used a higher contrast in post processing but that´s just my taste.

I feel the autumn fail — all that slow fire / denied in me, who has denied desire...
by Bear_Music

Comment:
Well sort of a nice job on the HDR processing but I can´t really say I find this image pleasing to look at, it´s just way way too busy for my taste. 5 from me.

The Road Less Traveled
by BakerBug

Comment:
When seeing images like this I always think they would be stronger with a subject walking down the path or towards the camera and this is one of those images but not bad at all, like the lighting and soft shadows on the pathway.

View from the old Iron Bridge
by MAK

Comment:
Yeah! Told ya you dork that you would ribbon sooner rather than later, you should listen to me more often cause obviously I know what I am talking about, hehehe :P

Congrats!