Spy Glass
by shangri_La_gypsy

Comment:
I think this is a very creative and beautiful photo. We all seem to be struggling with the guidelines for this challenge, and I am trying very hard to be fair. I don't think this fits the guidelines as I understand them. It appears to be more of a reflection than a framing. But it is very nice.

After re-reading the guidlines several times, I came back to reconsider this photo because it is so pleasing. I do think it fits the challenge and have raised the score accordingly. Good luck ;-)

The World Through A World
by joebok

Comment:
Very nice photo, in my opinion at least. Clear, colorful, fits the challenge. Just my personal preference, I would have liked a closer crop at the top -- for whatever it's worth ;-)

Separation of Church and Car
by boomer

Comment:
I like the colors. I don't think it fits the challenge as I understand it. It seems more of a reflection than a framing of something in the background. I know there's some disagreement about the guidelines for this challenge, but I am trying to be fair and consistent.

I came back and re-read and re-read and finally believe this does fit the challenge. I updated the score accordingly. Very nice photo. I personally don't like the title -- but since that wasn't part of the challenge I let it go ;-)

Doorway
by sndsgnl1

Comment:
Great photograph, in my opinion. It meets the challenge, as I understand it, and yet is beautiful apart from even knowing what the challenge was.

Like a llama...or an Emu
by Pedro

Comment:
One of my favorites in this challenge!

Okay, I went back through all the entries -- it is definitely my favorite! 10

Roof
by Carola

Comment:
One of my favorites in this challenge!

Caitlin
by surfinbird

Comment:
very nice photograph!

Through the Green
by eptasdi

Comment:
I do love this photograph!

Framed in Blue
by vaguilo

Comment:
I love the colors in this photo, I just don't think it meets the challenge -- at least not as I understand it. I know there's been some disagreement, but I'm trying to be fair and consistent. It is lovely, tho.

Fountain in the mist
by BKerr

Comment:
I love the atmosphere of the photo! Very dreamy!