September Hurricanes
by Konador

Comment:
Its a shame, because this would be an unquestionable shoe-in for the wind challenge blue, it is a genuinely terrific image.

Sun Voyager and the Moon
by Gauti

Comment:
This works well in black and white... though I do think Angrimur's shot of this subject in colour worked slightly better. If in fact you are Angrimur please disregard this comment :P. The moon definately adds another element, though there may be too much empty space at the top. 6

All of Hawaii was once ruled from here.
by scottwilson

Comment:
I think this shot would perhaps benefit from a little less water in the foreground... also it seems a little flat - needs a little something more.

Monument
by orvaratli

Comment:
Really like the use of negative space and the shadows here, it's a great subject for a shot like this. 8.

Leaf Landmark — Prominence is Relative
by platy123

Comment:
Definately an interesting take on the challenge, I would have preferred if you had simply titled it Prominence is relative, but definately a great idea here.

The Pyramid - Long Beach (CSULB) Landmark
by Zippy

Comment:
This is a wonderful abstract, you might lose out for not providing a context which demonstrates the prominence of this 'landmark' but I still really really like this. 8.

Message edited by author 2004-12-13 01:29:07.

Tower Bridge
by redmoon

Comment:
This is gorgeous, I do like the soft effect here, but can't help feel it is perhaps a little overdone... maybe a little overprocessed or exposure is too long (??) but otherwise great. 8.

World Class
by caba

Comment:
The framing effect here is terrific... and the green cast whether because of the windows or photoshop is also really effective. 9.

Dance
by Neil

Comment:
I do like this, though am a bit impressionismed out... to be honest I'm not a huge fan of this as a photography style, there have been a few that have grabbed me, but not many that would sustain my attention.

This is quite effective but again, not my cup of tea.

Spherical reflections
by anireno

Comment:
Okay the setup here is ridiculous, I scored you a 7 during the challenge, but clearly without stopping to think about how challenging the creation of this photo must have been.

If I had thought it through you would have got a 9 or a 10 from me.

I would apologise, but you've got a blue ribbon for your troubles, so I don't think you are feeling particularly horrible about it.

Congratulations on a brilliant effort.