Studebaker Planter
by David Ey

Comment:
The bench on the front fender and the building behind are distractions. The bench might be movable, and much of the building could be hidden by a different point of view and different cropping. It is an excellent subject. The building also results in the subject itself being underexposed.

A 4.

lay down your tracks
by Pixelprose

Comment:
I like seeing the world from the dog's point of view. Thanks for lying down on the job. The train, builidings, telephone poles all add to locating this switch. Although it is near overexposure on the right, I feel the overall picture is a little too muted.

An 8.

Revisited
by MJENNI

Comment:
Very nice. I would crop out Nearly everything above the highest point on roof, everything to the left and right of roof. The extraneous details detract from a what is a wonderful vintage scene. I would also like to have seen a longer exposure. There is not much moving here.

A 5. Much higher if brighter and less distractions.

Tango by the Ruins
by crude_art

Comment:
I feel this could have been composed so as not to have the tree visually contacting the dancers. Otherwise, I love subject and photo.

A 6.

life:death/green:rust
by AlexHugel

Comment:
I don't know what I am looking at but it is lovely. Reminds me of a salmon filet with green garnish. I would have liked the lower left corner to be as well exposed as the rest of the picture, but something seems to be casting a shadow over my desires.

An 8.

Birds of a Feather.... Rust Together
by amylyn

Comment:
The ground does not offer much contrast for the ankles and feet. Maybe taking th picture from ground level would help. That would also emphasize the height of a bird designed to be tall. The lighting could also be improved.

A 4.

For Sale Cheap - Contact Bonnie or Clyde
by photom

Comment:
I would like this picture better without so much sky. I also would have liked it better if it were taken while the sun still lit the engine. Unfortunately bullet holes remind me of the tears of those who have lost loved ones in all of human conflicts, not a pair of endearing thiefs.

A 5.

spanner works
by micro

Comment:
This composition does not work for me. I certainly like the needlenose pliers lying on the spanner, and the readable print of the book or magazine cover is also appealing. That leaves the plastic screwdriver handles, but they seem important to the shot as well. The lighting, focus, and picture processing are all excellent.

So, you get a 7 with my apologies for not knowing why I did not give you more.

Links
by peecee

Comment:
This is quite appealing. I would prefer the focus to be on the very left most horizontal link and then let the chain fade into oblivion with distance.

A 7.

Old Lock
by vtruan

Comment:
Besides being overexposed, the colors are over saturated. The compositon and subject matter look like this had the elements of a very interesting picture.

A 3.