Guarding Louisbourg
by pcphotos

Comment:
Best: Made me again consider the "Luey" vs. "Lewis" pronunciation...haha
Worst: too small, next time maximize the 720 pixels..

Autumn Apple
by Gryphx

Comment:
Best: An image like this comes along and proves again to me that its not all about bells and whistles... comp, tones, subject
Worst: its funny, but although this isn't my favorite image, this is the first where there is nothing wrong with it...huh, I guess that means I should at least add one point to my previously deduced score...huh.

Snoqualmie Mountains At Sunrise
by prbetts

Comment:
Best: very unique mountain
Worst: the yellow strip is just distracting, although I see what you are attempting...

Piercing Gaze
by L1

Comment:
Best: Subject, focus
Worst: foreground branch is distracting...

Darkness
by Marella

Comment:
Best: Setting, sky
Worst: just too dark..

Trapped
by gloda

Comment:
Best: You got my first giggle...that's a lot of magazine clippings...blur on face of course
Worst: Wait, let me get my bearings back, i am dizzy....

Mile Long
by nixter

Comment:
Best: sky, aggressive comp, setting
Worst: comp as well, if that makes any sense...it makes it more difficult to appreciate it...

~~sand~~
by tmhalling

Comment:
Best: setting
Worst: Next time try more dramatic editing to really enhance sand...

The Players
by pawdrix

Comment:
Best: I swear I recognize that dude on the right...I don't remember whose image this was, but I'll say it anyway..."Look, Jimmy, its Samuel L.!!!"...emotion and realness
Worst: composition

Glacial Valley Dawn
by hahn23

Comment:
Best: All that damn fauna! And of course the grandeur..sure looks like Colorado to me...
Worst: I wanna give benefit of doubt, but the scorching red just feels a bit fake and weird compared to rest of scene and exposure..