Beauty and the Beast
by kennyt

Comment:
I find the texture of the material rather unpleasent. Otherwise, good shot

Ivory Touch
by wkoffel

Comment:
I think this would have been a great entry if not for the opacity of the hands. Still, a 6

Hard and Soft
by incubus

Comment:
too centered and not sharp enough

touch to find the way
by yuki

Comment:
Nice concept, but a too many blown highlight to merit a top score.

The Master's Touch
by fotodude

Comment:
I know this will sound like a nitpick, but the fingernail should have been clean. Other than that, I like the photo and it meets the challenge

A mother's touch
by ssengupta

Comment:
I'm not sure if it's intentionally blurred or not but I would have like to have seen it sharper. The composition is good. 5

Gentle Giant
by riley

Comment:
I don't exactly understand your message here - but that's ok. The biggest problem is that the photo is out of focus so I'm marking it down for that.

Sticky Situation
by dsa157

Comment:
Great concept. I think the lighting is a little too dramatic and I would have liked to have seen the girls other eye. Still, It's a good photo and worth my 7

Contribution
by thatcloudthere

Comment:
I only rated the photo a 5 in the challenge because I didn't feel the smoke played a "major role" per the challenge requirements. To me, it seemed as if the shot was of a gorgeous sunset and an interesting silhouette - and oh, by the way, there is a smoke stack in it.

That being said, I think the photo is great and you should be proud of it.

Bill

Corona "Personal Writing Machine"
by Tuckersmom

Comment:
This one should have done better. I think many people did not have their observation skills engaged when they voted.