Hat and Chair Study
by nsmith

Comment:
My eye cannot stop staring at the arc of light painted above the chair. The blinds are also distracting. 4

Calla Lily
by Keith Maniac

Comment:
Framing is nice. Lighting is almost perfect (would like a teensy bit less glare on the left). A bit of noise that distracts me. I can identify the problems, but unfortunately offer no solutions. My own attemptt would have tielded similar results. 5 on technical merit, but giving it a 6 for the thoughtfulness in composition and particularly how the stem is lit.

Lake Bionicle
by whatdewuc

Comment:
Clever. Nice dof choice. would like the face a tad sharper. Also there seem to be compression artifacts in the water. 5

Yeux Silencieux
by film_de_verre

Comment:
IMO this suffers dramatically from over processing. It was obviously intentional, but does not suit my taste. 3

Let There be Light
by umbris

Comment:
much more interesting than I would expect. Coming back later to study this one more. 6 for now.

Marken
by Azrifel

Comment:
Very nice tonal range. The lights and darks really capture me in t his shot. Once I notice the leaning tower, it's really hard to pull my eye away from it. Is this lens distortion? 7

Sun, Sea and Boats (or what is left of it...)
by ChrisJ

Comment:
Interesting. I like the perspective. The model some how adds something to this, but the position seems awkward. Oh and the title needs some work. Nice photo altogether. 6

Asiatic Lily
by vontom

Comment:
This is nicely composed, but oversharpened. Softness would have added to this shot. Also, the grays are a bit flat. 5

March
by Pedro

Comment:
The skin tones suffer as a result of the boosted saturation. Her pose is nice, but her feet are not pretty (probably the angle); however cropping them out doesn't work either. A good effort. 6

March
by TommyMoe21

Comment:
Beware the "eyes" of march. lol.