Anne Geddes
by sigurdjon

Comment:
the background is too busy.
cropping tighter into the child would help eliminate some of that.

P-i-P (a nod to jjbeguin's lovely duotones)
by Melethia

Comment:
this is very good!
bumping up from 7 to an 8.
i like the simplisticness (?) of it and the twinning of the images.
i would like to try something similar myself.
good luck.

Paper Bark Trees & Lilies. Ansel Adams
by BrianR

Comment:
nice perspective and tonal range (whatever tht is :-))
I think this would look a lot nicer in a bigger format.
I think the 640 is not doing it justice.

el`e·men'tal : John Paul Caponigro
by Rikki

Comment:
very nice colors.
they almost clash too much, but I think they work.
At least that is my opinion.
good luck.

Untitled (Inspired By Uelsmann)
by MQuinn

Comment:
very surreal and freaky!!!
I like it a lot.
I'm not sure how you achieved it, but I'm looking forward to finding out.

Man Ray's solarized lillies
by LevT

Comment:
ah, Man Ray, I haven't thought about him in years.
Nice reproduction.
I like it.
Good luck.

Tribute to Andy Warhol
by nlghttrain

Comment:
I like the pop art of Andy Warhol.
this is a nice tribute to that.
a small nit pick (does that phrase refer to head lice?) would be to remove the stickers from inside the shoes.
there are only two and it didn't detract from the score I gave you (7), but i just think it would make it look better overall.
oh, i also wonder what this would look like with a different colored background?

She is sophisticated (tribute to Bernard Plossu)
by Pascal

Comment:
I like the anonimity(?) of the cut off head.
I even like the too dark shadows by her legs and the blown out whites of the books.
strange that.
good work and good luck.

Pepper No. 31 (Weston)
by mycelium

Comment:
kind of looks like a melted hershey kiss and a deformed human ear all in one.
yet I still like it and it is amongst my top votes for this challenge.
sorry I couldn't give any constructive help with my comment.

To Andre Kertesz; an appreciation
by e301

Comment:
I don't know who the tribute is to, but I trust you!
I really like the whole scene, but I think I would prefer a little more contrast in the black and whites.
there just seems to be too much "grey" in it.
but then again maybe that's what the tribute person does?
I'll never know!!!!!