Still of the Morning
by Skip

Comment:
I disagree with Linda. While it would be nice to have a row of trees in the background, that dark area does add some punch, and the crop is right where it should be. Cropping further would throw the balance off, and cloning more water above the bird would result in a blandly symmetrical composition. My only complaints are minor: the horizon isn't quite straight, and there appear to be some sharpening artifacts around the egret. This image would sell on DPCPrints.

Appomattox
by Skip

Comment:
This shot is my favorite in your Landscapes collection. Great color and composition. I'd probably crop the left side at the corner of the fence to eliminate the turn and the messy tree edge. Keep this spot in mind for a future challenge and come back when it's foggy, sunrise, etc...

Stillness of the Night
by tyt2000

Comment:
Another top-10 finish by tyt2000... *yawn*

You are clearly caught in a rut of way-above-average photos. Congrats!

Green River (Water Chestnuts)
by Neil

Comment:
Nice landscape, poor challenge concept. Your score is riding entirely on the strength of the green color and pretty composition. While two-thirds of your image is plant life (thus preventing any 1 votes), Nelzie nailed it- it's not obvious which plant is the focus of study. Your best bet here might have been to literally spell it out in the title: "Water Chestnuts Invade the River," or "Foreign Invader Takes Over the River."

Boy Fish
by Neil

Comment:
Indeed, an excellent illustration and a wonderful example of the extension of photography into art. Fine use of color and composition. That said, I prefer the dazzling colors in your motion blur flower experiments.

Message edited by author 2004-10-21 00:23:42.

Sounds of Life
by prozac

Comment:
My wife said, "How do you know that's Hopper?" Well, you got me! Welcome to the agonizing world of challenge scores. You're probably just a better model than Kris. ;-)

Hello?
by bongo

Comment:
Looks like I wasn't the only one to pick this for blue. Congratulations!

U.S. Mail
by Gringo

Comment:
Excellent subject and good use of selective desat. A bit grainy, but suitable. Did you try sepia? 8

'Morse Code Extreme'
by Ambo

Comment:
One of my favorites in this challenge. The DOF is too shallow for my taste, but I'll be surprised if this doesn't make the top 10 anyway. 8

Hello?
by bongo

Comment:
My pick for the blue. Good luck! 10