Work's Done
by ChrisW123

Comment:
Great shot - this is the kind of country I'm use to seeing. The detail and colours are wonderful.

Relax with the Reflections--after cutting the grass!
by Patzt

Comment:
Good attempt given the challenging lighting (bright sky, dark foreground). The grass looks a little too well kept to be "country" though. I like the composition of the tree and river - very nice.

Country Wheels
by heida

Comment:
Great perspective although I might have tried focusing on the hubcap.

Bubbling Mud Pots
by BAMartin

Comment:
Critique Club

Composition: I love the various textures included in this shot - the smooth mud, sharp rocks, rust coloured earth and even some steam. It's perhaps a few too many elements to combine but I actually kind of like it. I have to admit though that the photo has two focal points - the mud and the pit. A different crop may have made one focal point more powerful.

Technical Quality: You have captured the colours and textures incredibly well. I have nothing to complain about - no blown highlights, not oversharpened - just plain well done.

Meeting Challenge: I guess some people might argue that mud is water, but I think you easily met the challenge. It's certainly an interesting form of liquid - especially its behaviour.

Border / Title: The title is fine, and helps clarify what might otherwise me a confusing subject (the bubbling effect is laregly lost in a still photo). I think this shot might have been framed better with a small border - and that's probably the first time I have said a border would help.

Overall: It's a lovely shot, and will act as a great momento of your trip. I really like the various textures - the smoothness is such a contrast to the sharpness of the surrounding rocks.

Welcome
by LeahStephen

Comment:
Good work. I was just looking at your photo and I agree with shadow... The black and white image is very good but probably doesn't echo the "home sweet home" theme. It looks a little bit cold. I would try to recolour the photo to a sepia (brown / orange) type of colour.

Besides that the image is very good - lovely detail, lovely exposure and lighting. There is some parallax (ie: top of buildings narrower than bottom) but it's not major. The border is ok - almost too large but just ok in my opinion.

"Neo, Trinity... NOW!"
by swaroskji

Comment:
Critique Club

Composition: You have used an extreme close up of the phone but it works well. It's fairly obvious that it is a phone and the reflection is wonderful. The background on the right side is a little distracting because it's not obvious what it is - although making it so blurred prevents it from distracting the viewer.

Technical Quality: The photo is very good from a technical stand point. Good exposure, lovely colour (very appropriate to the challenge)

Creativity: I love the subject matter - the phone is so significant in the movie and adding a character was a wonderful idea. I'm guessing it's an image from a poster or DVD cover or something similar - great idea.

Meeting the Challenge: You have easily met the challenge - the subject, title and coloring of the photo are spot on.

Overall: For only your second contribution you have done a wonderful job - well done. I look forward to your future work since this entry is so good.

There is no spoon!
by The Kid

Comment:
Nice tie-in to the movie and the white background reminds me of all the times they enter the program without a background (like when selecting guns). The reflection in the spoon is a little distracting since the spoon was seen indoors and the reflection looks like trees and a fence. Great work though.

It’s Chinese to me!
by pollonos

Comment:
Unfortunately there is very little photographic skill to comment on. I understand the title but the photo is boring and does not provoke interest.

Blue
by EJ

Comment:
That's really interesting. Is it some kind of sea creature?

Hyper Drive
by DennisF

Comment:
Wow - I love the focus effect you achieved. I'm guessing the train you were on is moving with a long exposure. I love the result.