Under the Pier
by elemess

Comment:
Nice idea but the ocean is sort of boring in this shot, while the cross bracing is interesting. If you had taken the shot lower, would the waves have looked bigger and shown more of the peir?

Parallel Reflection
by luckycharmsrock

Comment:
Good reflection, weak parallel.

Time to Look and Learn
by agwright

Comment:
Too much middle grey. 80 % of the image is within two zones. Very nice subject matter and composition, good POV. I wish it was left in color or more contrast was used in the conversion.

Cow Paths
by alanfreed

Comment:
I wish the barn was in better focus. good subject, nice framing.

Parallel & Intersecting
by Jeileen

Comment:
lovely colors in the building but the lack of interest and amount of space put into the driveway hurts this shot.

Brooklyn Bridge
by dougmc1

Comment:
Nice framing but if you are going to transform the shot to black and white, I wish I could see black and white as well as middle grey. Not enough contrast here to serve the subject matter IMHO.

My Sister Got Busted and I'm the One Who Did IT!
by Melly8522

Comment:
too much USM looks like it was printed on canvas.

Wasting time silently in the library
by MadMountie

Comment:
I don't know if this shot really answers the challenge. I don't know if this is really in a place that is quiet. I do know that you chose a dynamic POV and got great colors. This is my favorite shot of the challenge. I don't know why.

By the Light of the Moon
by mariomel

Comment:
A lot of ideas were repeated over and over in this challenge. I have been seeing a cabin in the woods, a cabin in the snow, a house in the night, ect. This however is well enough done that it becomes THE cabin in the woods. It sings a common song so well that it makes the song it's own. The use of red foreground light to balance out the blue of the night sky , and the blown out lamp repeated in the blown out moon, create a still balance that make this a special shot.

Sweet Dreams
by jodiecoston

Comment:
Im sure you will get the comment that you took away too much contract or blew out the details.They will be wrong. You caught the moment of waking up next to someone you love very very well. The lipstick smile ( a bit too perfect for mornig, but it looks good) and the ring balance nicely and high keying catches the mood of mornig wake up perfectly. Nice job