Broken
by Dim7

Comment:
not sure, but i'm guessing the broken part of the image here is what looks like either a strangely shaped fallen tree or (much more likely) an abandoned car. however, not sure most people will catch this - a different angle might have emphasized this aspect of the photo better. good colors/contrast however.

Circle Of Life
by faidoi

Comment:
interesting. not sure i like the negative space at the top, or the close cut to the tail at the bottom - perhaps a different angle. texture is great, and so is the contrast.

Broken But Not Beaten
by Karalew

Comment:
interesting use of this common subject - if you want to use one light source however, i would prefer to have it illuminating the broken side of the egg, its insides, and the pan rather than the untouched/unbroken side. possibly including the entire egg would be beneficial as well.

No! Not the HB!
by ursula

Comment:
great idea, with some humor included as well. two suggestions: one, the two shadows is semi-distracting (just for normal situation/reality purposes) - it does happen, but in this case it just reminds me that it's a setup shot with (i'm guessing) two lights shining on the pencil. two, get a newer and smoother textured pencil (and maybe sharpen it as well) - texture is sometimes interesting, but a smooth texture would appeal more to me here. still, a good shot and worthy of a solid score.

Shattered Thoughts
by KDO

Comment:
interesting. i feel the gradation to black is a little too sudden for my tastes, but this is a good idea and an interesting twist on this common subject.

Oops
by scottwilson

Comment:
oh no - hate it when that happens. perhaps less lighting on the hand would help improve this interesting shot... or if you're feeling daring, i have an inkling that a very shallow DOF that only keeps the cork in focus would work quite well here (if that's possible - i realize everything is at a relatively equal distance from the camera)

Neglected and Run Down
by Heavy

Comment:
interesting, but purple hue of the sky gives it a look that i'm not sure is best for this image. perhaps a darker/rustier looking hue/saturation modification for the truck would work wonders.

Fortune and Misfortune
by Keith Maniac

Comment:
haha - interesting. maybe a rearrangement of the middle cookie (it seems to remove some attention away from the fortune) combined with slightly less DOF.

Broken Stem
by DCThiessen

Comment:
i like your choice of alignment. so far it's the only 'orderly' broken glass that i've seen in the challenge, which makes it interesting. choice of a cool-toned background color also provides the 'calm' environment that helps fit with this orderly arrangement. well done.

Scene from my Nightmare
by nico_blue

Comment:
intense. normally i would say it looks overexposed, has a color cast, and some vignetting - but they all seem to give it a unique look that is appealing this time around.